January 16th, 2013

The Problem with “Personalized Learning”

James Paul Gee:

People who never confront challenge and frustration, who never acquire new styles of learning, and who never face failure squarely may in the end become impoverished humans. They may become forever stuck with who they are now, never growing and transforming, because they never face new experiences that have not been customized to their current needs and desires…

Success in the 21st century at work and in life requires collaboration, collective intelligence, and smart teams using smart tools. In our fast-changing world, a world that faces many serious crises, being able to cope with challenge, to persist past failure, to learn in new ways, and to adapt one’s skills and style to other team members are all 21st-century skills. Yet new technologies and the Internet allow us to enter our own customized echo chambers and identity niches where we can comfort ourselves with what we are and do not have to confront ourselves with what we can be and, indeed, must become as fellow citizens in a diverse and complex global world. This is particularly dangerous for students.

What happens when people with different “sweet spots” have to learn, solve problems, and collaborate with others who have different “sweet spots,” as people so often have to do in modern workplaces? I wonder what would happen should, God forbid, children run into learning situations in the world that cannot be optimized for them individually. What if the world changes and the problems that arise just do not afford solutions that fit their sweet spot? What if their sweet spot is just no good for certain types of learning and problem solving?

This is the problem with adaptive platforms that attempt to “personalize” learning to each individual’s inherent strengths. We don’t live in a world where only our inherent strengths make a difference. By eliminating struggle and failure, we risk more than we realize. 

  1. irvingirv reblogged this from willrichardson
  2. viivaalaaviidaa reblogged this from willrichardson
  3. thelearninglife reblogged this from willrichardson
  4. teachreadingwrite reblogged this from allisonunsupervised
  5. mitsubishi-corporation-lt-mclogi reblogged this from willrichardson and added:
    Chang Gung University Court Guishan , Taoyuan TaiWan Next Media
  6. polymomma reblogged this from allisonunsupervised
  7. allisonunsupervised reblogged this from grayer and added:
    This is just not a problem with personalized learning; this is too often a problem with standardized school. Students...
  8. earcos-connect reblogged this from iamlittlei
  9. subjectivemeaning reblogged this from willrichardson
  10. w1thbr0kenw1ngz reblogged this from iamlittlei
  11. iamlittlei reblogged this from grayer
  12. tasteofadeadsun reblogged this from willrichardson
  13. dcarls26 reblogged this from willrichardson
  14. alejot127 reblogged this from willrichardson
  15. ronjonsurfshoppe reblogged this from willrichardson
  16. grayer reblogged this from willrichardson and added:
    Sometimes struggling and a little bit of suffering are the best teachers.
  17. aefschools13 reblogged this from willrichardson
  18. willrichardson posted this
Loading tweets...

@willrich45

Likes

Welcome! I'm Will Richardson, parent, educator, speaker, author, 12-year blogger at Weblogg-ed and now here. I'm trying to answer the question "What happens to schools and classrooms and learning in a 2.0 world?" Best selling new book: Why School?s...order now!!


Because Modern Learners Need Modern Leaders


My Latest Book!
Just $1.99!!!