July 22nd, 2011

Why the Tests Don’t Work

This is about as succinct an argument against standardized tests as I’ve come across yet. Written by William Wraga, a professor in the program in educational administration and policy at the College of Education, University of Georgia, it’s in response to the cheating scandal now rocking the Atlanta Public School System, and it clearly lays out the case that we are not doing much to assess our kids’ knowledge OR promote a learning disposition when we use them.

Research has found that when high-stakes tests are used:

1. Educators will teach to the tests.

2. Curriculum narrows to that which is on the test.

3. Instruction narrows to skill-drill test prep.

4. Academically disaffected students are more likely to drop out of school.

5. The pressure to raise scores in the face of severe sanctions increases the incidence of unethical behavior.

Research has not found sufficient evidence to support the notion that implementing high-stakes tests will improve student learning. In short, research suggests that high-stakes testing accountability measures not only will not improve education, but also may actually undermine education. Why would we enact a policy that would do that to educators and students?

Even without the research, this isn’t rocket science, is it? Very little of what we test is useful knowledge to any individual child, and we basically have no idea to what extent students can build on that knowledge nonetheless. It’d be nice if we trusted teachers a bit more to do that. 

(Do take a moment to read this reply to get the gist of the dysfunction in our thinking about this. The system is just doing a horrible job of teaching critical thinking, obviously.)

  1. rufusmcki reblogged this from willrichardson
  2. classroom-stu reblogged this from willrichardson
  3. sugartech reblogged this from willrichardson and added:
    This is about as succinct an argument against standardized tests as I’ve come across yet. Written by William Wraga, a...
  4. atypicalteacher reblogged this from willrichardson
  5. kenyabenyagurl reblogged this from willrichardson
  6. schmeeko reblogged this from willrichardson and added:
    THIS THIS THIS!!! omg. i was one of those kids who cried every time the scores were given back. i was always in the...
  7. hollensturz reblogged this from willrichardson and added:
    —- I’d like to add something and quote this part:...Also, it’s not about learning...
  8. delightfuldowney reblogged this from willrichardson and added:
    Thank you, Mr. Richardson, for inspiring me...for sharing easy to understand articles like...
  9. nerdytennisrunner reblogged this from willrichardson
  10. willrichardson posted this
Loading tweets...

@willrich45

Likes

Welcome! I'm Will Richardson, parent, educator, speaker, author, 12-year blogger at Weblogg-ed and now here. I'm trying to answer the question "What happens to schools and classrooms and learning in a 2.0 world?" Best selling new book: Why School?s...order now!!


Because Modern Learners Need Modern Leaders


My Latest Book!
Just $1.99!!!