Will Richardson

Speaker, consultant, writer, learner, parent

  • About
    • About Will
    • Testimonials
    • Contact Will
  • Blog
  • Speaking
  • Coaching
  • Books
  • BQI

Basketball is Life

July 18, 2016 By Will Richardson 6 Comments

tuck2As some of you may have seen on my Twitter feed Saturday, my son Tucker and his teammates at SportsU won the Under Armour Association 16-U championship in Atlanta this weekend. It’s an elite team in an elite program playing an elite schedule, and I’ve never seen better basketball at the high school level than this spring and summer. (We’re on to Las Vegas this week for the last tournament of the season.)

I’ve been struck by all of the things that Tucker has learned in this experience, things that will serve him his entire life. Let me just say that while he is a very good basketball player, this team that he joined up with this year for the first time is just amazing. The starting five (who have been together for five years now) will almost certainly all be Division 1 players in college, and one is unquestionably an NBA prospect. Suffice to say, this was a real step up for him to play with these kids.

But he did well, was sixth or seventh man in most games, usually got a good amount of playing time against the highest competition, and had varying levels of success on the court. But it’s off the court that I just want to briefly focus on. Here’s his basketball “education” so far this year:

He took a risk. He could have played for any number of AAU teams, but given the chance to be on the best team and play at a higher level of competition, he took it.

He overcame adversity. There were moments this season that he had to prove himself, when things didn’t go as planned. He kept his head up always.

He showed resiliency. In those few really bad moments that almost every player experiences during a season, his reaction was “I gotta work harder.”

He assimilated to a new team and culture. Like I said, this team had been together for a while, and earlier in the season one of the other parents told me that they had been tough over the years on “new kids” joining the team. But she immediately said “They like Tucker, though.”

He gained confidence. Even though there were moments that I knew he wanted to play better, there were very few moments (if any) where he looked like he didn’t belong at that level. He’s much more in tune with his potentials now.

He deepened his passion. There’s no doubt any more what he’s working toward: a Division 1 offer.  He loves to play.

He learned to honestly assess his abilities. Sure, he got feedback from his coach and teammates. But mostly, he did a lot of reflection on what he needs to improve at.

He worked hard on something that matters. I’ll be very happy when he gets his license in about a month because as much as we don’t mind driving him to practices and gyms and games and everything else, he’ll have the freedom to set more of his own workout schedule. Regardless, he’s learning how much hard work it takes to succeed at this level.

And there’s more…lots more. But that’s a start.

And you know what I’m going to say, right? Why can’t he get all of those things and more from his time in school? All that stuff above, that is the stuff that matters in life, the stuff that he’s actually going to need to flourish, yet that’s too often absent with the work he’s being asked to do in the classroom. Please don’t tell me they’re mutually exclusive; they’re not.  And don’t tell me it’s not possible in schools; I’ve seen it. It’s just rare.

Look at how kids learn when they are engaged in things that matter to them. Isn’t that what school ought to be?

Regardless, I’m so thankful that my son has a deep love of the game. I wish all kids could experience that level of passion for something in their lives.

Filed Under: learning, Personal

“The Fatal Disconnection of Subjects”

July 15, 2016 By Will Richardson 5 Comments

zen deleteHere’s your Friday moment of EduZen to think about over the weekend. As always, would love to hear your thoughts. Thanks for reading this week.

Alfred North Whitehead (1916):

The solution which I am urging is to eradicate the fatal disconnection of subjects which kills the vitality of our modern curriculum. There is only one subject-matter for education, and that is Life in all its manifestations. Instead of this single unity, we offer children—Algebra, from which nothing follows; Geometry, from which nothing follows; Science, from which nothing follows; History, from which nothing follows; a Couple of Languages, never mastered; and lastly, most dreary of all, Literature, represented by plays of Shakespeare, with philological notes and short analyses of plot and character to be in substance committed to memory. Can such a list be said to represent Life, as it is known in the midst of living it? The best that can be said of it is, that it is a rapid table of contents which a deity might run over in his mind while he was thinking of creating a world, and has not yet determined how to put it together.

Filed Under: EduZen

It’s Really “Personalized Teaching”

July 14, 2016 By Will Richardson 8 Comments

We talk a lot about personalized “learning.”

But what we’re really saying is personalized “teaching.”

Either the human or the algorithm deduces the gaps and then supplies “personalized” curriculum to fill them. Either way, the student is the object of the personalization. Someone or something else is deciding what the student “learns,” and how it’s assessed.

And we know we’re teaching. We don’t really know if the learner is “learning,” however.*

Whether or not you want to use that technique, or purchase that software, let’s just call it what it is and acknowledge who is doing what in the transaction.

If the object is to move agency over the learning to the learner, to let the learner decide what questions are of interest, and what paths to take to knowledge, that’s truly “personal learning.”

Let’s do more of that if we really believe kids now need to be powerful learners on their own.

(* Unless you define learning as remembering something long enough to pass the assessment.)

Filed Under: learning, On My Mind

The Digital Ordinary

July 12, 2016 By Will Richardson 3 Comments

As much as I agree with my friend Chris Lehmann that “technology should be like oxygen: ubiquitous, necessary, and invisible,” we’re still a ways off from all of that. But if I forced you to choose the one of those three adjectives that we’re struggling with the most in schools, which would you select?

I think I might go with “necessary.” Seriously, how much of our practice in classrooms to we absolutely need technology to accomplish? Looking stuff up on the Google has pretty much replaced traditional research, no doubt. But beyond that? Is technology necessary to create the things we ask kids to create? (It might be more so if we dealt with things kids asked to create.) We could still do grades, take attendance, all the stuff the typical LMS stuff serves up. (We did all that before the LMS, remember.) And it’s nice to collaborate on Google Docs, but we did that before the Internet as well. Digital textbooks? To me, that’s all pretty ordinary stuff.

6844396458_38ef8c8e50_bTechnology should allow us to do the extraordinary, right? To connect live or asynchronously with people from all over the world. To publish stuff to a global audience. To make things, programs, artifacts, inventions that can’t be made in the analog world. To write in multimedia. To remix and create in new ways. To do “extra” stuff that you can’t do without the technology. That should be the bar.

I’m reminded of that when people start talking about Chromebooks and one to one programs. The price of Chromebooks can make the technology ubiquitous. And the low maintenance part can make it nearly invisible (though that has more to do with culture than technology.) And those are good steps.

What’s interesting is when I ask people who currently have MacBooks or full-fledged Windows laptops whether they would swap that device for a Chromebook, no one ever volunteers. That suggests that we know what we’re giving kids isn’t extraordinary. We’re pretty much making the ordinary digital.

Seriously, would love people to prove me wrong about that.

(Image credit: Ant Standring)

Filed Under: On My Mind, Technology

Our Empathy Problem

July 11, 2016 By Will Richardson 2 Comments

delete kidEmpathy and “design thinking” and attending to the “end user” are all the rage these days, and with good reason. They are responses, I think, to the increasing separation we’re feeling in our world between the haves and have nots, different races, different political persuasions. Everywhere, the fault lines seem to be expanding, and we seem to be searching for ways to close the gaps by attempting to understand “others” more deeply, by walking in their shoes, as it were.

This is really hard, of course, because all any of us truly understand are our own lived realities. Everything else is a guess, educated or not.

I’ve been thinking about that lately as the events in the U.S. over the last week have caused most (many? some?) of us to seek deeper empathy and understanding for others in order to try to make sense of the killings and violence. How well can we fully know the lived experience of another, of another’s culture or heritage, of another’s profession? Can “empathy” ever be reached fully? And how do we live empathically in our day to day lives?

That’s not to say that seeking understanding isn’t a worthwhile effort. We should aspire to start with the “other” whenever we can.

On some level, perhaps our difficulties with living empathically begin in schools. When we first greet five and six year olds at the door, how well to we design their experiences with a respect for their own lived experiences? As they go through school, are we continually asking “Who are you?” “What do you care about?” “What motivates you to learn?” “What do you need?” Do our students feel that we are fully seeking to understand them as individuals? Do we, as Seymour Sarason (and others) have asked, bend our practice to their needs and desires, or do we ask them to bend their practice to ours?

The answer is obvious. And the effects there are obvious as well.

If we started with the “other” in mind, if an attempt to respect and understand outweighed our own deep-seated narratives and fears, perhaps we’d see the gaps disappear all together.

(Image credit: Shannon Kelley)

Filed Under: On My Mind, schools

Technology as the Object of Our Inquiry

July 8, 2016 By Will Richardson 14 Comments

zen deleteHere’s your Friday moment of EduZen to think about over the weekend. As always, would love your thoughts:

Neil Postman in The End of Education (1995);

What we needed to know about cars–as we need to know about computers, television, and other important technologies–is not how to use them but how they use us. In the case of cars, what we needed to think about in the early twentieth century was not how to drive them but what they would do to our air, our landscape, our social relations, our family life, and our cities. Suppose that in 1946, we had started to address similar questions about television: What would be its effects on our political institutions, our psychic habits, our children, our religious conceptions, our economy? Wouldn’t we be better positioned today to control television’s massive assault on American culture?

I am talking here about making technology itself an object of inquiry, so that Little Eva and Young John in using technologies will not be used or abused by them, so that Little Eva and Young John become more interested in asking questions about the computer than in getting answers from it.

I am not arguing against using computers in school. I am arguing against our sleepwalking attitudes toward it, against allowing it to distract us from more important things, against making a god of it.

What questions should we be asking about our technologies?

Filed Under: EduZen Tagged With: Neil Postman

Embracing “Rapidly Changing Times”

July 7, 2016 By Will Richardson 1 Comment

If you follow me on Twitter, you know that I Tweet a fair amount about climate change, and how it’s something that we’re going to need to help our kids cope with on all sorts of different levels. From where I sit, this is now the work of schools, engaging students in the important questions we face and helping them develop the skills and dispositions to answer them and problem solve their way through it. I think of my own kids in this regard all the time. Are they ready? Will they flourish? Will the enjoy their lives?

Through our new Changeleader Facebook group, I found Superflux:

We work closely with clients and collaborators on projects that acknowledge the reality of our rapidly changing times, designing with and for uncertainty, instead of resisting it.

“A world in flux” feels totally right. Cultures around the globe are colliding with “historically unprecedented force.” We now have “local and global crises arising daily from our collective inability to deal with ever-faster change.” Political upheaval, racial tensions, economic uncertainty…I can’t think about it too long before I start feeling queasy.

179299295_1024a70998_bBut I do think about it. And we need to think about it with kids in our schools as well. We need to “acknowledge the reality of our rapidly changing times…instead of resisting it” in our classrooms, for the sake of our kids.

For instance, Superflux is thinking about “mitigation of shock” that will no doubt occur as the globe heats up.

The disconnect between scientific, data driven predictions of global warming, and the lack of immediately visible signs contributes to a space of cognitive dissonance, its implications unsettling and ominous. But it is also a space which offers the opportunity to confront our fears, to experiment with ways in which the shocks of the impact of climate change can be mitigated. It is in this space that we at Superflux have situated our research and design project: Mitigation of Shock.   We want to conduct experimental design responses to first world disasters that are likely to happen in the near future, by prototyping alternatives today. Tools, methods, materials and commons that individuals can learn, use and share in order to gain agency and capacity to mitigate the shock of climate change.

Tell me, why wouldn’t that be a worthwhile goal and challenge for our students? To “gain agency and capacity to mitigate the shock” of what is almost undeniably coming their way?

I know that these are difficult subjects to discuss with kids. But we resist at their and our peril. And we’ll all be better served if  the next generation is comfortable (as it can be), engaged, and capable with embracing uncertainty head on.

Asking questions that we don’t know the answers to would seem a logical place to start.

(Image credit)

Filed Under: Classroom, General, learning

The Wrong Focus

July 6, 2016 By Will Richardson 5 Comments

Train (v) – “teach (a person or animal) a particular skill or type of behavior through practice and instruction over a period of time.”

From CDGW’s EdTech Focus on K-12:

In a recent survey by Education Dive, sponsored by Sprint, 86 percent of respondents agree that teachers in their district need more training in educational technology. Unlike Price of LAUSD, 41 percent of respondents say they don’t believe their districts have an explicit plan that lays out for teachers how educational technology can be most effectively used in lessons and curricula.

6917574943_eb479afe70_bIf you want to understand more fully the larger problem we have in education, it is this: just like our students, teachers are waiting for someone to teach them something rather than just going out and learning it.

I’m not saying there isn’t value in teaching stuff or skills or other things in the moment.

But to suggest that more “training” for some future lesson is somehow going to transform the use of technology in classrooms once again misses the point.

This is not about teaching. It’s about learning.

If we’re focused on building plans that “lay out for teachers how educational technology can be most effectively used in lessons and curricula” then nothing will change. Nothing.

I ask this a lot: Anyone know of a nine-year old kid who was “trained” to learn Minecraft? Took a workshop in Snapchat? Why should we be ok with adults waiting for a workshop?  

Why should we be ok with adults waiting for a workshop?

Click To Tweet

If you really want to change things, focus on culture and on developing more kid-like dispositions in the adults to use technology to learn, not just to teach.

Don’t, as the CDGW article suggests, start by “making technology the focus.”

Instead, start by making learning the focus.

(Image credit: NWABR)

Filed Under: On My Mind, Professional Development, Teacher as Learner

The “Achievement Gap” vs. The “Relevance Gap”

July 1, 2016 By Will Richardson 6 Comments

zen deleteHere’s your Friday moment of Eduzen to think about over the weekend. As always, your thoughts welcomed.

Harvard’s David Perkins in Future Wise: Educating Our Children for a Changing World:

We might consider another gap alongside the achievement gap. Let’s call it the relevance gap. The achievement gap asks, “Are students achieving X?” whereas the relevance gap asks, “Is X going to matter to the lives learners are likely to live?”

If X is good mastery of reading and writing, both questions earn a big yes! Skilled, fluent, and engaged reading and writing marks both a challenging gap and a high-payoff attainment. That knowledge goes somewhere! However, if X is quadratic equations, the answers don’t match. Mastering quadratic equations is challenging, but these equations are not so lifeworthy. Now fill in X with any of the thousands of topics that make up the typical content curriculum. Very often, these topics present significant challenges of achievement but with little return on investment in learners’ lives.

Here’s the problem: the achievement gap is much more concerned with mastering content than with providing lifeworthy content.

So why don’t we see more attention to the relevance gap alongside the achievement gap? Well, attention to the relevance gap upsets the apple cart of conventional practice much more than attention to the achievement gap. The achievement gap is all about doing the same thing better. With the achievement gap as our target, we want to do a better job imparting skills and understandings we already try to teach. But embracing the challenge of the relevance gap asks us to reconsider deeply what schools teach in the first place. Topics and themes that have been part of typical curricula for centuries might get displaced, reduced, or reframed. Textbooks might need rewriting. Teachers would find honored parts of their disciplines under siege and new and tricky content knocking at the door— barbarians at the gate! To borrow from Al Gore, the problem of lifeworthy learning that so pervades typical curricula is an inconvenient truth. As with our planet’s precarious situation, ignoring an inconvenient truth is a dangerous way to deal with it (30-31)!

 

Filed Under: EduZen

The Value of “Invisible Learning”

June 30, 2016 By Will Richardson 4 Comments

I spent 18 years teaching high school, 22 years total in a public school, and even though I left a decade ago now, I do remember this: Almost nothing I learned in college prepared me for the realities of the classroom. My first week of student teaching stressed me out so much that I got a total of around 10 hours of sleep Monday thru Thursday. The only reason I survived it was because my co-operating teacher had a party that Friday night at which he made sure to keep a fresh beer in my hand (among other things) until I gained some “perspective.”  When he felt I was “ready” to hear it, he slung his arm around my shoulder, looked me straight in the eye and said, “Will, you’re taking this much to seriously,” after which I somehow got myself home, poured myself into bed and slept for like 18 hours.

My “perspective” was much improved on Monday.

Anyway, my initiation into teaching is not the point of this post, at least not the major point.

17278203012_4890031d0d_cAs I was at ISTE in Denver last week, I started thinking about all of the presenters up there on the various stages or in the front of the breakout rooms, wondering how was it they arrived at that moment. Wondering how much of what they were presenting about had they learned in a formal, classroom, education-y setting. Remembering how I arrived at my first presentation in Dallas at the 2003 Journalism Education Association conference where three people showed up to hear my musings on “Blogging in the Journalism Classroom.” (First question: “What’s a blog?”  Sigh.)

When you look through the ISTE program list, you’ll find the occasional research study or paper being shared. But most of what you’ll see is people talking about practice, whether it’s tools or pedagogies, or projects or whatever else. It’s personal experience intended to help others understand the value to kids and how those in the audience might take it for their own.

I’m pretty sure those presenters didn’t figure out how to do the things they were presenting about by taking a course or a workshop and then writing up an application to present at ISTE. Instead, what they’re showing off is the fruits of their own personal (not personalized) learning labor over time, the results of trying, of failing, and of wanting to learn more. Of working with others, comparing notes, reflecting, collecting various forms of data…a soup of primarily tacit learning developed “on the job.”

That’s borne out by a highly scientific survey that I posted on Twitter this morning. Here are the results as I write this:

twit1

Fully 90% of the respondents say that most of what they currently do was learned “on the job.”

So, what’s my point? This: Learning for kids in schools should be much more “on the job.”  I mean if we ourselves have learned how to learn out of need or desire, in tacit ways with others, for sharing with real audiences, why wouldn’t we create the same conditions for kids?

I was reminded of this today when I watched a presentation by John Moravec, whose concept of Knowmadic Learning and his Manifesto 15 have both been influences on my own thinking. In this particular presentation, he talks about what he calls “invisible learning,” defined as “placing trust in learners and shifting the flow of power from the top-down to the learner-out.” He adds:

We learn more, and do so invisibly, when we separate structures of control that restrict freedom and self-determination from learning experiences.

I love that, and I have a feeling most of the presenters at ISTE this week were self-determined, “invisible” learners who had the freedom to pursue their interests in ways that they designed and structured. And now, they had a chance to present their learning to an audience of interested peers hoping to learn from them. That’s a pretty cool end to a natural cycle of learning.

But, I guess, not appropriate for our kids.

(Image credit: InUseExperience)

Filed Under: On My Mind, Teacher as Learner

Reflecting on #ISTE2016

June 30, 2016 By Will Richardson 6 Comments

“Common sense” is an interesting term, isn’t it?

What’s “common”?

What is “sense”?

Just because something makes sense to me, doesn’t mean it makes sense to you. I get that.

But some things just seem so obvious to me:

Schools should be about learning, not teaching.

Technology should be about helping kids become better learners, not helping the adults become better teachers. (Someday, the learners will be on their own, right?)

School should be fun. It should be “genius” all the time, not just an hour a week. It should be about discovery and wonder and passion and good deeds in the world.

Learning is not centered in curriculum; it’s centered in creation. In composition. In questions and missions.

And we adults should do what we believe when it comes to creating the conditions for kids to learn deeply and powerfully with us, not from us.

Why we would do anything else?

If that’s not “common sense,” what is?

Filed Under: learning, On My Mind

Common Sense on Curriculum

June 28, 2016 By Will Richardson 5 Comments

I know I’ve been on a bit of a “common sense” jag lately when it comes to the systems and practices of schools. The way we think about curriculum is no exception.

So, to that end, just thought I’d share a video that I just came across from Larry Rosenstock of High Tech High. Because common sense.

What do you think?

Filed Under: Curriculum, On My Mind

From Changemakers to Changeleaders…Join us!

June 27, 2016 By Will Richardson 3 Comments

(NOTE: I’ve fixed the links to the community below. Sorry for any inconvenience!)

A couple of years ago now, my friend Bruce Dixon and I created ModernLearners.com in an attempt to help educators at all levels build their capacity for the change conversations in schools that are so urgently needed. We’re both amazed at how quickly we built a list of thousands of readers of our newsletter and blog posts, and we’re proud at the impact those efforts seem to be making.  

But while it’s great to have readers, we think it would be even better to have a community of committed educators who are passionate about really changing the way we think about schooling to more effectively serve the modern learners who come to our classrooms each day.

So, to that end, I want to invite you to join our free Global Community of Changeleaders (GCC)  on Facebook, a space where the people who want to push the education conversation to the edges of what’s comfortable can meet to share stories, ask questions, interact directly with us on a regular basis, and learn the best ways to create sustainable change.

A space where the members are working to build a different, not just better experience for the kids in our schools.

14859431605_1fcfc06f74_bThe good news is that “different” is happening more and more each day. In our travels and online, Bruce and I are talking to more and more educators who have fought through their frustration with the current system and begun the hard work of fundamentally rethinking their work in schools.

But we’re also hearing that those change efforts are disconnected. That there is a desire for those seeking “different” to find others engaged in that work, for ideas, for questions, and for support.

That’s why we’re creating the GCC, and we’d love for you to be among the first to join us.

To officially introduce our community, Bruce and I will be on Facebook Live inside the group this Tuesday night at 7 pm US Mountain time, coming to you from the ISTE 2016 conference in Denver. We’ll talk a bit more about our hopes for the community and take some of your questions as well. (And we’ll probably make some vendors mad at us at the same time.)

You won’t want to miss it.

And one other change!

We’re excited to announce that long-time educator and community savant Missy Emler will be joining the Modern Learners team. You can learn more about Missy on our site, and she’ll be a big part of our work in the GCC Facebook community and beyond.

Finally, we all know that making real change happen is hard enough to do when you’re working on your own.

Sharing your experiences in our community will provide a forum where you can be more reflective and benefit from the wisdom and experiences of other changemakers from a diverse range of backgrounds. So please consider becoming a member.

So, join us!

We have great ambitions for where Modern Learners will be going over the next 12 months, and we want you to be part of the journey. In the meantime, I’m looking forward to engaging with you in this new community.

As always, thanks for the support.

(Image credit: **RCB**)

Filed Under: On My Mind, Personal

The Problem With the “Disciplines”

June 24, 2016 By Will Richardson 1 Comment

zen deleteHere’s your Friday moment of EduZen to think about over the weekend. Your thoughts welcomed. Enjoy!

Russel Ackoff:

There is no longer the slightest justification for introducing children to the idea that human thought is a collection of fragmented “disciplines” and making that idea the center-pin of the educational experience for students in their schools. As a historical curio, this idea might make for an amusing aside in a general discussion of the evolution of human thought, but as a notion that is productive and useful for developing minds it is, at the very least, counterproductive. Children grow up seeing the world as a whole. Their greatest challenge—one that continues to be the central task of every person throughout life—is to form a worldview that makes sense out of the multitude of their experiences. Indeed, human sanity depends on the integrated nature of a person’s worldview; fragmented psyches are generally considered ill-adapted to the needs of adult survival” (Kindle 950).

Filed Under: EduZen, learning, schools

“Teaching Ourselves Out of a Job” Redux

June 23, 2016 By Will Richardson 5 Comments

1477899923_5fb736f33c_zFrom the archives, September 14, 2005:

What I realized more clearly last night is that for many teachers, the idea of teaching kids to be able to access information and find mentors and communities of practice basically means teaching themselves out of their jobs, at least as they know it. I mean, at some point, we’re going to have to let go of the idea that we are the most knowledgable content experts available to our students. We used to be, when really all our students had access to was the textbook and the teacher’s brain. But today, we’re not. Not by a long stretch. And we don’t need to be. What we need to be is connectors who can teach our kids how to connect to information and to sources, how to use that information effectively, and how to manage and build upon the learning that comes with it. That’s a much different role than “science teacher” or “math teacher.” Now I’m not saying that subject matter expertise is irrelevant and that there aren’t core concepts that discipline specific teachers shouldn’t teach. But they should be taught it a much wider context, not in the fishbowl this is our traditional classroom.

It still strikes me how little this conversation seems to have changed, over the past 11 years in this case. How many teachers currently see themselves as connectors? As curators? As models for learning?

I wonder what I’ll be writing about this 11 years from now…

(Image credit)

Filed Under: On My Mind, Teacher as Learner

To Shakespeare or Not to Shakespeare

June 22, 2016 By Will Richardson 8 Comments

Shakespeare re-entered my life this week, a couple of decades removed from when I used to teach him in a Brit Lit class at my old high school. My shocking English teacher confession is that I never really enjoyed Shakespeare, both as a student or a teacher. I didn’t see the point. My literary heroes were Cheever, Roth, Updyke, Vonnegut  and their ilk, both in school and in life. I just found the more contemporary American authors much more engaging and interesting and relevant.

A couple of days ago in a workshop, after I was pressing hard on the idea of the “just in case curriculum,” an English teacher came up to me at the break and asked, “But what about Shakespeare? Don’t all kids need Shakespeare?” It was somewhere around the 589th time I’d gotten that “Don’t all kids need to learn…?” question, and my response was the same as most of the other occasions: “I don’t know, but I doubt it.”

As always, Roger Schank has a bit less nuanced response, referencing The Oddessy rather than Hamlet:

Why do we insist on teaching things that kids don’t care about and have no reason to care about?  Is this a very clever way to behave? How do students who don’t care manage to get by? Is their future made more difficult by not caring about such stuff?   I argue that it is.”

I tend to agree.

Turns out that some educators in the U.K. do think Shakespeare is a plus for learning. Research out of King Ethelbert’s School showed that after launching into a program of teaching and performing the Bard, proficiency on the school’s exit exams rose from 14 percent to 55 percent. It’s not clear that there is definitive causation between the two events, but apparently other studies show that Shakespeare has helped improve writing skills and heightened brain activity in kids. All good.

I wonder, though, if it’s Shakespeare, or if it’s the passion for Shakespeare on the part of teachers and the school that changed the outcomes. I wonder if the students found a passion for the works because they had a chance to explore them deeply, surrounded by a culture of learning and performing that brought it to life in ways that I couldn’t in my classroom. That happens all the time. It happened to me in my first writing class in college where the T.A. who was teaching it just magically made me fall in love with “The Essay” as a genre. I probably owe much of my current writing life to her willingness to share her joy for it, and her desire to make us love it as well. And I tried to make that happen with my own students when I started teaching exposition a few years later. Just like in my college class, some did, some didn’t.

That was also hammered home by a conversation with Tim Bedley on a podcast I did with him and his brother yesterday.

Again, I was talking about “the curriculum question” when Tim noted that he’d just sent a whole bunch of kids out into the world with a love of the American Revolution, no doubt made possible by his own love of the American Revolution. Our passions, or lack of passions, as teachers have a huge impact on our kids.

So what does all this mean? To be honest, I’m not sure. I don’t know what every single child needs to learn in school in a curriculum context. I do know that it’s not anywhere near as much as we currently think, especially now that curriculum is everywhere online. By forcing every child to take every thing, by forcing them all to read Shakespeare or all to take Trig, I’m sure we’re turning off as many kids to reading and literature and math and the rest as we are turning on, if not more. Teaching and schooling is not an exact science, and just because one school near Shakespeare’s home improves outcomes by making kids read him doesn’t mean that’s going to necessarily happen anywhere else (assuming we wanted to “improve outcomes” in the first place.) Nor is it honest to say that if I child doesn’t read Shakespeare in school she’ll never read it anywhere else.

And nor does it seem possible in the current system that every student can have a teacher who LOVES Shakespeare and can make King Lear come to life for them. That’d be nice, but…

To me, it comes down to this: Do we want our kids to learn to love reading on their own or to love Shakespeare? To love the math that surrounds them in their individual worlds or to all check the Calculus box? To learn to be historians in their own unique ways or to all memorize histories that may serve them well on Jeopardy one day?

I know for some kids, these aren’t either/ors. But a serious cost/benefit analysis about “curriculum for all” is way, way overdue.

Filed Under: Curriculum, On My Mind

The “Normal” School Year Should Be Anything But

June 21, 2016 By Will Richardson 2 Comments

16414436262_4a4ded9c85_cYesterday, I noted that much of what we think and do around learning in schools defies common sense.

Today, I’m reminded that the kids know it too.

In Muscatine, Iowa, over 700 students are participating in a two-week summer program called College for Kids. They’re building things with Legos, messing around with oobleck goo, and using all sorts of tech to make robotic cars, and much more.

The program coordinators describe the need:

Students get ‘hands-on learning experiences they may not have time or resources to have during the regular school year…We fill in the gaps that a normal school year can’t do; it gives them a chance to be creative, use their imaginations, think outside the box.’

The goals are clear.

We want them to walk away with loving to learn more…they are learning, not just hands-on but technology, we have iPads, computers, projectors.”

Teachers love it.

Our teachers that come here, they also get the opportunity to teach a lot of things they don’t have a chance to and they love it.”

Kids love it.

We’re using fun kids toys with science, to make fun learning,” one student says. Others say “they liked having a chance to build projects on their own and follow the instructions themselves.”

But, the kids also get it.

It’s hands-on so you get to build it instead of just the teacher building it and you just answering a question,” one student said [Emphasis mine].

Ugh.

Common sense would say that if you’re doing something that kids love, that teachers love, that promotes wanting to learn more, and that accentuates the growing discontent with “regular” classroom learning, you might want to think about doing that stuff full-time instead of just for two weeks in the summer.

Think: “Our Curriculum Hour” instead of “Their Genius Hour.” Make the “genius” stuff the norm and carve out some time for the curriculum when necessary. Heck, they’ll get most of the curriculum through their genius anyway.

The worst part? Kids have to “score a 75 percent or above on the Iowa Assessment to qualify, or be recommended by teachers.”

Does that make any sense to you?

(Image credit: m-shipp22)

Filed Under: learning, On My Mind, schools

The “Common Sense” Argument

June 20, 2016 By Will Richardson Leave a Comment

Last week I spent a chunk of time talking education with a couple of family members, one of whom is a teacher at a “high performing” district in Connecticut. It was a pretty aimless conversation, but it kept coming back to a certain question: “Why do we do that, again?” And a certain response: “It just makes no sense.” We must of said that at least a half dozen times in a 45-minute conversation.

I know I’ve riffed on this before, and I don’t want to do a deep dive into it again, but it still astounds me the extent to which we in education look at our practice and fully acknowledge that it’s hard to justify in a developing-kids-as-learners context, but we just keep doing it anyway. Easier for us vs. better for kids. Trying to do the wrong thing right. Etc.

Today while I was working with a group of educators in Central Pennsylvania, I decided to use that as the starting point for a discussion on why we need to rethink, really rethink schools.

Mechanicsburg

And the ensuing conversation reminded me that the “Why?” question is really not so much about why we do the things we do…tradition, nostalgia, training and more. We all get the history.

The real “Why?” question is “why do we keep doing the things we do?”

Especially today.

Filed Under: On My Mind, Professional Development, schools

“Outright Mistaken”

June 17, 2016 By Will Richardson 1 Comment

zen deleteHere’s your (late) Friday moment of EduZen to think about this weekend. Would love to hear your thoughts.

John Holt:

Only a few children in school ever become good at learning in the way we try to make them learn. Most of them get humiliated, frightened, and discouraged. They use their minds, not to learn, but to get out of doing the things we tell them to do–to make them learn. In the short run, these strategies seem to work. They make it possible for many children to get through their schooling even though they learn very little. But in the long run, these strategies are self-limiting and self-defeating, and destroy both character and intelligence. The children who use such strategies are prevented by them from growing into more than the limited versions of the human beings they might have become. This is the real life failure that takes place in school; hardly any children escape.

When we better understand the ways, conditions, and spirit in which children do their best learning, and are able to make school into a place where they can use and improve the style of thinking and learning natural to them, we may be able to prevent much of this failure. School may then become a place in which all children grow, not just in size, not even in knowledge, but in curiosity, courage, confidence, independence, resourcefulness, resilience, patience, competence, and understanding. To find how best to do this will take us a long time. We may find, in fifty or a hundred years, that all of what we think of as our most up-to-date notions about schools, teaching, and learning are either completely inadequate or outright mistaken. But we will make a big step forward if, by understanding children better, we can undo some of the harm we are now doing (xii).

(Written 49 years ago…)

Filed Under: learning, On My Mind

Let Go or Be Dragged

June 16, 2016 By Will Richardson 2 Comments

zendeleteChange is hard. That’s an understatement.

Change is inevitable. That’s just truth.

We want certainty, because certainty makes it easier to define ourselves, to carve out our value. To measure our work against long-standing, consistent expectations. To say that we are a success. To stay safe.

That mindset limits our ability to deal with the inevitable, however. And the consequences for ourselves and those around us can be profound.

Letting go means embracing and working to understand change in all of its subtle and powerful forms. It means choosing to move and evolve and grow.

And despite the angst of not knowing, that’s a lot better than being dragged.

Filed Under: On My Mind

“I Don’t Need Your Network…” Revisiting 2009

June 15, 2016 By Will Richardson 5 Comments

deletecityNow that I finally have all of my 3,700 lifetime blog posts here on one site, from time to time I want to look back on some of the ones that drew the most commentary/discussion, or ones that I just think are interesting to reflect on.

In December of 2009, I wrote a post titled I Don’t Need Your Network (or Your Computer, or Your Tech Plan, or Your…), and over a couple of weeks, it attracted 152 comments. And let me just say, the comment thread is better than the post itself. (Seriously, if you have the time…)

So what’s changed in the 6.5 years since that post went live?

Short answer: Not as much as I think I expected. I mean, aren’t we still pretty much asking these questions?

  • If at some point in the fairly near future just about every high school kid is going to have a device that connects to the Internet, how much longer can we ask them to stuff it in their lockers at the beginning of the day?
  • How are we going to have to rethink the idea that we have to provide our kids a connection? Can we even somewhat get our brains around the idea of letting them use their own?
  • At what point do we get out of the business of troubleshooting and fixing technology? Isn’t “fixing your own stuff” a 21st Century skill?
  • How are we helping our teachers understand the potentials of phones and all of these shifts in general?

The ubiquity of phone access, even for kids who come from the lower end of the economic spectrum, has arrived. In developing countries, smart phones are becoming essential tools for learning, education, business, community and almost everything else. By the end of this decade, 5 billion people in the world will own a smartphone. Does that in-our-pocket access serve as an important context for the decisions we make in our schools and classrooms?

Let me just say (once again) that I’m struck by the level of respect and civility in what at times becomes a fairly heated discussion that takes many different directions and offers many different examples on both sides of the debate. That’s getting harder to find.

And on a personal note, I think this post comes from the period when I was at my pinnacle as a blogger. The Twitter effect was just about to take root. I was starting to blog less and Tweet more, a trend that I’ve been trying to reverse in the last few months. Either way, it’s definitely interesting having an archive to look back on.

Would love to hear your thoughts.

(Image credit: Seth Doyle)

Filed Under: Blogging, On My Mind, Tools

Trajectories, Not Jobs

June 14, 2016 By Will Richardson Leave a Comment

skydeleteSome comment threads are actually readable. (Forget ones about politics.) And some comments in those comment threads are actually enlightening and instructive. Here’s one:

Donna Brewington White:

My kids do not dream of growing up and finding a job. They dream of creating (and selling) something or starting something… My 15 y.o. son sees his popularity on Vine as the beginning stages of his future work as a filmmaker. For him it is a trajectory.

For context, White’s response was to a post by Fred Wilson on the expansion of the highly popular writing and reading site Wattpad into Wattpad Studios, aimed at connecting “entertainment and publishing executives with Wattpad stories and creators.” And in case you’re not familiar with Wattpad, that means connecting them to thousands and thousands of kid authors who create and comment and commune on the site on a regular basis. I’m guessing some of those kids are in your schools.

Bu the larger point, I think, is this. Sites like Wattpad are places where kids can write about things they find interesting or are passionate about for an engaged, most often supportive community of readers, many of whom are writers themselves. Others, like Vine, or Snapchat, or YouTube offer other mediums and other audiences for kids to create and share. For many, this is the new normal.

Except in schools.

I wonder how many of our students feel the license and agency in schools to create their own “trajectory.” And I wonder what we, and they, miss by not making that a focus of our work in classrooms.

Wattpad Studios will no doubt bring kid creators more fully into the entertainment mainstream, to amplify their passions and good works, to grow their audiences. The good news is they’re not going to wait for us to figure it out.

(Image Credit: Zachary Young)

Filed Under: Connective Reading, Connective Writing, Media, On My Mind, Tools

Required: Rethinking Curriculum

June 13, 2016 By Will Richardson 1 Comment

What percent of what we learn in our adult lives is learned via a curriculum that someone else explicitly put together for us vs. a path of content and people and whatever else that we create on demand for ourselves in the moment? Especially now with the Internet?

In my life right now, I’d say it’s 90%-10% in favor of the self-created path. I’m guessing most people reading this are nodding their heads.

Now ask that same question of kids in school. In my own kid’s case, he says it’s almost the exact opposite.

6626010553_548212cb1b_b

It’s not hard to see that our focus in schools isn’t on learning as much as it’s on making sure kids become learned about the “best-guess” curriculum we put in front of them. Similarly, it’s hard to argue that that approach is getting them ready for the 90%-10% world of self-determined learning that we all know they’re going to live in.

Here’s truth: We now have access to more uniquely relevant and interesting resources for any given child to learn from and with than any organizationally selected curriculum could possibly offer.

Which is why the school curriculum should now be an act of creation instead of a highly scripted package of content for completion.

To quote Dave Cormier:

I’m starting to believe, more and more, that given THE INTERNETS, content should be something that gets created BY a course not BEFORE it. Our current connectivity allows us to actually engage in discussions at scale… can that replace content?

Interesting question…

(Image credit: Evelyn Giggles)

Filed Under: Classroom, On My Mind, schools

Why Our Kids Need Schools That Learn

June 10, 2016 By Will Richardson Leave a Comment

zen deleteHere’s your Friday moment of EduZen to think about over the weekend. Adult beverage suggested…

Phillip Schlechty:

In the digital world, print- and person-dependent learning is not the rule. And as businesses are beginning to learn and religious leaders are beginning to discover, these new technologies threaten existing boundaries and existing arrangements of power and authority in fundamental ways. Organizations that are change adept–that is organizations that can learn as well as encourage learning–will survive and thrive in this new world. Organizations that require stability, tranquility, and predictability will perish. And bureaucracies absolutely require stability, tranquility, and predictability if they are to function in optimal ways…

If the limitations of bureaucracies continue to be imposed on or accepted in schools, the only alternative available to those who desire a high-quality education will be to create a new system of education outside the range of the state and federal bureaucracies that now dominate public schools. Indeed, such a system is likely to function outside schools more generally, as most private schools are structured on the same organizational premises that guide public schools, and thus are based on assumptions that are not valid in a world where digital learning opportunities abound.

If schools both public and private cannot become more adept than they now are at absorbing and supporting disruptive technologies–and it is clear that digital technologies, properly exploited, will be disruptive in bureaucratically organized schools–then customized, commercially provided education is likely to replace both public and private schools, at least for most students. Those left behind will be the children of the poor, who will be trained in state-run bureaucracies rather than educated in outstanding schools, making even more real the social class divisions that are tearing at America’s social fabric (21).

See you Monday.

Filed Under: On My Mind

The Five Questions That Most Define My Work

June 9, 2016 By Will Richardson 3 Comments

6107062655_61eba7be5f_oIt’s interesting to me the struggle that schools seem to have with allowing student led inquiry learning to become the norm in classrooms. After all, our lives are driven by questions, and the pursuit of interesting questions is the vehicle through which we learn most effectively. Think of any great invention, any great achievement, for that matter almost every act in our lives; they all start with questions, large or small. And like adults, kids learn most profoundly around questions that matter to them.

Why wouldn’t we make inquiry the foundation of our learning work in schools? For both teachers and students? (Good question.)

I’ve been thinking about the questions that drive my work a lot of late. I’m wondering which are really worth pursuing, as in which do I think actually have an answer that is within reach of both my feeble brain and my time left on Earth. (Change in schools is very slow, in case you hadn’t noticed.) To that end, I’ve been making a list of all the questions that I’m asking that seem most interesting to me in relation to the work I’m trying to do. I’m up to 27, but just for posterity, I thought I’d share the top 5 at this moment.

  1. What happens to schools at a moment when information, knowledge, teachers, and technologies for learning are readily available and carried in our pockets?
  2. Why is there a disconnect between what most educators say they believe about how learning occurs and what they practice in classrooms?
  3. What are the skills, literacies, and dispositions that our kids will need in order to flourish in their lives?
  4. How do we bring relevant, sustainable change to legacy systems of education?
  5. What don’t I know about how people, and specifically kids, learn with or without technology?

These still pale in comparison to “How do I raise two kids to be productive, happy, caring, engaged, loving human beings who love to learn?” But they’re where my professional head is at for the moment.

Hoping you’re willing to share a question or two that’s driving your work and your learning right now. #5questions

(Image credit: Virtual EyeSee)

Filed Under: learning, On My Mind

  • « Previous Page
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • …
  • 152
  • Next Page »

Recent Posts

  • “Never”
  • My 2023 “Tech Cleanse” Has Begun
  • Five Themes for Educators in 2023
  • Schools in a Time of Chaos
  • Has This Crisis Really Changed Schools?

Search My Blog

Archived Posts

Copyright © 2026 Will Richardson · All Rights Reserved

Follow me on Twitter @willrich45