Will Richardson

Speaker, consultant, writer, learner, parent

  • About
    • About Will
    • Testimonials
    • Contact Will
  • Blog
  • Speaking
  • Coaching
  • Books
  • BQI

Survey: Internet Grows as Campaign News Source

January 14, 2004 By Will Richardson

(via Doc Searles) A little off topic, but I think it’s a trend that will continue, and one that will more and more include some type of blogging.

Internet news sources posted the largest relative gain, as 13 percent of those surveyed said they regularly went online for campaign news and another 20 percent saying they did so occasionally. In 2000, only 9 percent said they regularly turned to the Internet. Younger Americans said they relied less on traditional news sources, turning instead to cable news, the Internet and comedy shows such as Saturday Night Live for campaign news.

Not great news about the last part, but I can’t help but think this trend will continue.

More important is this essay: News Is A Conversation. I absolutely love this part:

It is this power and influence that drives mainstream journalists to look at new media types, especially bloggers, and describe them pejoratively as the “vanity press,” “self-important,” or worse. The question, of course, is if bloggers derive their sense of importance from themselves, then from whom does the mainstream press derive theirs? You see, there exists within journalism today a belief that this power and influence of theirs is a right, a guarantee given to them by some higher authority, and therein lies the rub. This belief is further enhanced now that certain, very well paid journalists find themselves on the same societal and cultural levels as those about whom they report. This is treasonous, for the roots of journalism are fed by the blood of those who gave their lives for the free flow of information.

This is not only why the mainstream media doesn’t get it yet, it’s why they don’t want to get it. If Howard Dean is successful in his presidential bid, it will really shake things up.
—–

Filed Under: General, On My Mind

Meet the Press…uh, Blogs

January 11, 2004 By Will Richardson

MR. RUSSERT: He now loves Iowa. One of the things that we will find out is just how truly effective is the Internet in this presidential race? Johns Hopkins University has already been studying it. Look at this: “The Use Of Blogs In The 2004 Presidential Election,” a study by Johns Hopkins University. And now for the computer illiterate crowd, this is a blog. This is Howard Dean’s blog. Here’s Wesley Clark’s blog. Here’s George W. Bush’s blog. And here to help us is Chuck Todd of National Journals Hotline.” What is a blog?

A pretty funny and not very astute discussion of Weblogs on Meet the Press today. You can’t help but watch this (or read the transcripts linked above) and not feel like the press still doesn’t get it. I think it’s that they just don’t want to.

David Broder had the best line in the discussion, however, when he said

“No, but I think it’s a tremendous tool, and it’s part of what is the healthiest trend in our politics, which is going back to personal communication, away from the mass media—forgive me, NBC. But I think the healthiest thing that’s going on now is people talking to people, either through the Internet or, as we’re seeing on the ground in Iowa, face-to-face communication.”

He, at least, is getting it.
—–

Filed Under: General, On My Mind

Blogging "Ideas of the Year"

January 5, 2004 By Will Richardson

I look forward to reading Dave Pollard’s posts when they come across my aggregator because he usually crafts very passionate essays on the environment or deconstructs any other number of political or social issues that may be topical. I’m really amazed at how much he writes. His post today sums up his “Ideas of the Year” within the world of blogging, and I think some of his points are well taken in education circles as well. You need to read the full post, but here are the highlights:

  • There are no rules in the “blogosphere”
  • It’s more important to be first than best
  • Focus on a few subjects and address them profoundly and creatively
  • Social Networking will allow us to build deep relationships, collaborate on awesome projects, find the next president.
  • Blogs could be the platform for a proxy for each of us as individuals, our electronic filing cabinet and electronic identity
  • The abandonment of 80-90% of blogs is a positive phenomenon
  • Blogging is increasingly a platform for achieving mainstream recognition
  • The culture of blogging is evolving faster than the technology (Note: Sound familiar?)
  • Blogs, like diaries, are a substitute for intimacy
  • RSS is blurring the distinction between blogs and other media

    Now I’m not saying I necessarily agree with everything on his list, but it’s a lot of food for thought. And from Dave, it’s positively optimistic compared to his Ten Things to Keep You Awake list.
    —–

  • Filed Under: General, On My Mind

    Blogging and RSS in Schools

    January 3, 2004 By Will Richardson

    This should be from the “Shameless Self-Promotion” dept., but here is a piece I wrote for MultiMedia & Internet @ Schools. Kind of interesting actually, in the midst of this somewhat unsettling conversation about blog hype, that this very rah-rah article about Weblogs and RSS comes out now. Not that I’m not still a big believer in this stuff, but just because we seem to be hitting a very natural and necessary bump that is exposing some of the messiness that the article can’t get to. In fact, it seems more and more of us are reassessing what all of this means, including some of the bigger names in the “industry.”

    That’s another aspect of Weblogs that I like. The article doesn’t have to end in the magazine; the conversation can continue here and many other like-minded spaces. Anyway, if you have any comments or just want to fact check the text, please feel free.

    Filed Under: General, On My Mind

    Rhapsody

    January 1, 2004 By Will Richardson

    Totally off topic, but I just have to rave about Rhapsody which will probably be the end of my CD buying days. I know it’s not new, but after a write-up in the Times today, I decided to try it out. About $100 a year to listen to as much streamed music as I can fit into my day from over 400,000 songs in their library. If I want to burn any of the songs to CD, I just buy each for 79 cents. (Not every song can be written to CD, however.)I’ve spent the last three hours stocking my library with over 150 albums from my college days right through Annie Lennox’s new one, which if you haven’t heard it is simply awesome. In those three hours of streaming through my wireless tablet PC, only one brief pop. Amazing. I can download the Rhapsody software to as many computers as I want, my library and playlists are saved on their server so I can access them from any of my computers, and I can create hours worth of mixed and matched music that I love without having to even turn on my CD player. I need to do a little digging into running this through my reciever and big speakers, which I’m sure might require some additional configuring. But I am simply amazed at how easy and how wide a selection is available. Not everything I wanted, mind you, but more than enough to keep me occupied for a long, long time.
    —–

    Filed Under: General, On My Mind

    Blog Hype

    December 31, 2003 By Will Richardson

    Pat Delaney was the first ed blogger that I came across 2 1/2 years ago when I first stumbled on Web logs. At that time, the whole concept was pretty much under the radar, and even with some serious digging, nothing turned up anyone who was doing more thinking and writing about blogs in schools than Pat. He was and continues to be an inspiration.

    So when Pat, in response to a post on Ken Tompkins site, writes “I’ve begun to wonder if there is any value to blogging beyond ‘hype,'” I can’t help but take notice. And on his own site today, Pat says

    “…the bloom is off the blog. Which is to say that if I’ve discovered anything this year about writing online it’s that “online” is NOT the best place for writing that aims at anything other than pointing.”

    To give Pat’s observations some context, he’s been playing with Tinderbox of late (which unfortunately has no Windows version.) His early reviews seem to be leading his ratcheting down of Weblog worth, so much so that a couple of days ago he quipped “blogging, schmlogging.” I’d be less than honest if I said his words haven’t given me some pause.

    I know I’ve been coming to the point where I’m needing some real results as to the power and usefulness of Weblogs. Now that enough teachers have kicked the tires so to speak, many are wondering about the engine and whether or not it can take us to where we want to go. For the English teacher, right-brained folks like Pat and Terry and I, these questions focus directly on writing process. I know that when I first started using blogs with my students, the biggest pull was the publishing aspect, that part of the process that I always felt lagging. The freewriting, the muddled and messy drafting, the peer response…all of those pieces felt pretty well addressed in my classes. But the work and time that went into finding non-manufactured audiences for my students’ writing was almost always too intensive to make it work. With Weblogs, it was almost too easy.

    I haven’t been convinced that Weblogs are great for process. The tool I use, Manila, needs some more switches to flip in terms of private and public posting that I think would make it more effective with the pre-publication stuff. We’ve been posting for over a year on the difficulties of all public space. There’s just a lot of messy stuff that writers do that needs to be done in private, and I think that’s what Pat refers to in the excerpt above about writing offline. Weblogs, and Manila in particular, weren’t created for the creative or expository writing teacher in mind. We’ve been working with a less than perfect tool, and maybe Pat’s just come to the conclusion that from a writing perspective, blogs aren’t going to cut it. In their current form, he may be right.

    But I still think Weblogs, and in particular Weblogs in schools, are more than just hype. From my experience, they are a heckuva lot better than folders, they facilitate communication between peers, mentors, parents, and teachers, they provide discussion space for thinking and writing not done in class, and they provide an easily accessed (for the most part) archived and searchable record of all sorts of work and knowledge. And those potentials as a communication and collaboration tool I don’t think have come close to being realized yet.

    And I think there’s something to be said for blogging as a genre, as a way of writing that doesn’t fit into our traditional definitions of composition but has some inherent value nonetheless. The blogging process isn’t as messy as other forms of writing, but the product can bring about some meaningful learning for students in terms of critical thinking and media literacy. There is much yet to explore here.

    Toward the end of his post today, Pat says

    In less than a week using only its basic applications, it’s [Tinderbox] become my primary writing space. A little testing of it as a note and bibliographic organizer shows it’ll be my primary researching and informational reading tool as well. It’s led to less blogging and more researching, reading, thinking and writing. Uh oh, sounds like a resolution…

    I hope I’m not reading that right, ’cause it sounds as if Pat’s moving toward taking his forward thinking ideas offline, leaving us with an occasional well-processed no doubt excellent piece of writing. I’ll be looking forward to reading it, but I hope he’ll continue to share his struggles too because that’s really where I think the power of of many of the Weblogs I read is, the immediacy of ideas in their sometimes inchoate, un-thought-through form. I’ve learned a lot from him and others through their messy spaces. I hope that continues in 2004.

    Happy New Year, everyone…

    Filed Under: General, On My Mind

    Ed Blogging 2003

    December 30, 2003 By Will Richardson

    Just want to take a couple minutes to recap my 2003 from a blogging sense. A lot has changed, I think. More teachers and students blogging. More good writing to read. More great thinking about how best to employ this technology. Even though we may not yet be as close to the “tipping point” for ed blogging as I once thought, one look at my aggregator shows just how much innovative thinking there is going on out there. So here, in no particular order, and with very little in the way of explanation, are some ed bloggers of note and some others thrown in from the past year.

    Most Enthusiastic Ed Bloggger–Anne Davis
    Best Over My Head Ed Blogger–Tom Hoffman
    Ed Blogger Rookie of the Year–Nancy Peralta
    My Favorite Blogger in a Non-Educational Role–Jay Rosen, Josh Marshall (tie)
    Ed Blogger I’d Most Like to Write Like–Terry Elliot
    Ed Blogger Site Redesign of the Year–Pam Pritchard
    Most Relevant (to me at least) Classroom User of Blogs–Kaye Trammell
    Environmental Blogger of the Year–Dave Pollard
    Student Blogger of the Year–Suzan S.
    Most Missed Ed Bloggers–Sarah Lohnes, Sebatian Fiedler (tie)
    Ed Blogging Principal of the Year–Tim Lauer
    Best Use of Metaphor to Explain Consistently Important Ed Blogger Thinking–Pat Delaney
    Higher Ed Blogger Who Best Translates to K-12–Dan Mitchell, Mike Arnzen, Ken Smith (tie)
    K-12 Ed Blogger Site of the Year–EdBlogger Praxis
    Ed Blogger App of the Year–Bloglines

    Some major ed blogging questions I’d like to get answers to in 2004:

    Do Weblogs improve a student’s ability to write? (Terry?)
    Can you build an online community with a Weblog based school Website?
    Is the skill of blogging important enough to teach as a separate genre?
    Will Manila development lead it to greater heights, or will it slide further into obscurity?
    Who is going to provide access to blogging for the thousands (if not millions) of kids out there who currently don’t have it?
    Will Weblogs allow for more participation in the political process for students and teachers?
    Where will Ed Blogger II be and when? (New Orleans in June???)
    Can I keep up a personal and professional Weblog at the same time?

    There are many more people and many more questions to note, I’m sure. This has been a wonderful year for me thanks in large part to the new friends that I’ve made in the Ed Blogger community, the opportunities for blogvangelism that have come along, and the very cool work that my students and teachers at my school are doing with Weblogs. It’s one of the many things I’m looking forward to in 2004. To all of you who have contributed to this journey, my heartfelt thanks, and my sincerest wishes for a peaceful and prosperous new year.

    Filed Under: General, On My Mind

    Persepective

    December 26, 2003 By Will Richardson

    Spent a good chunk of yesterday at the Trenton Area Soup Kitchen with my wife and father-in-law helping to dish up over 400 meals to some very less fortunate on a cold New Jersey day. It’s amazing to me that in my state capitol, the illiteracy and poverty rates are both around 40%, and that’s literally less than 25 miles from my community where I would be surprised if either of those rates broke 2-3%. It was depressingly obvious how bleak the prospects are for the children who came through the doors. For me, their faces make it very difficult not to wonder why we can spend billions on the reconstruction of countries that we really have no business destroying in the first place but we can’t find enough money to provide the basic necessities for our own people…
    —–

    Filed Under: General, On My Mind

    Happy Holidays

    December 24, 2003 By Will Richardson

    All the best to friends new and old and others just wandering through; may all of your celebrations be warm, peaceful, and memorable. –Will

    Filed Under: General, On My Mind

    Hitting a Wall

    December 16, 2003 By Will Richardson

    I feel a much needed break from blogging upon me, even though it could get exciting around here when Bryan finishes up his new modular theme for my school site. I’m am itching to start creating, so hopefully it will be soon. One of the theme issues with Manila that’s always been tough is the difficulty in providing pre-created, editable content WITH the theme, for reasons that are too complicated to go into here. But Bryan is working on a solution that could make things much, much easier in terms of personalization. More later…if I can dredge up some energy.
    —–

    Filed Under: General, On My Mind

    Graphic Problems

    December 16, 2003 By Will Richardson

    It’s probably just as well that more and more people are using RSS to read Web logs because then they don’t get to see how bad a page looks when the graphics don’t load. I’m not sure what the problem has been over the last few days, but it’s a nice reminder that just when you start forgetting that technology is not perfect it jumps up and bites you. At least the functionality of the site is ok. Hopefully, the banner will return later today.
    —–

    Filed Under: General, On My Mind

    Poor Choices

    December 12, 2003 By Will Richardson

    This is totally un-Web log related, but just too funny to not share. The following is a piece of an e-mail that our principal received yesterday:

    “Dear Ms. Brady,
    I discovered that I could receive an accounting of what my son was purchasing for lunch each day. When I received it I was very disappointed to learn that of $200 on his account he spent approx. $17 on Little Debbie cakes, $20 on French Fries, $49 on Soda (Gatorade), $12 on ice cream, $27 on pizza, $10 on pretzels & candy and $57 on lunch. As a result he owes me $143 for his poor choices…”

    Sheesh. Now that’s what I call brain food…
    —–

    Filed Under: General, On My Mind

    Blog Out

    December 11, 2003 By Will Richardson

    Things are already crazy enough in my world to be making this blogging stuff feel even more like work than it should. And it’s not surprising that some people give up the blogging ghost for any number of reasons. I’ve been wondering actually how I’ve been able to get in here as much as I have considering the pace of my professional and personal life. (And into what category does this venture fall, anyway?) I think what I realized is that so much of my life is immersed in this stuff that it’s hard to get away from it. And this space has really come to be the place I dump my thoughts and learning and general stuff about how I’m using them. Most people aren’t overseeing 200-plus sites, or creating school newspaper blogs and classroom blogs and student blogs and god knows whatever else. (And, of course, “Teach blogs? Blog.”) Shoot, my wife is even designing Web log Websites for local businesses. What’s next? Scary.

    But the other big piece of it, of course, is that I believe in it as a really powerful tool for schools. If I was just keeping a Web log to lament the state of the world, it would be different. Not that there is anything wrong with that, in fact I wish I had the time to do that. But this is more than just writing…
    —–

    Filed Under: General, On My Mind

    My Kids Won't Like This

    December 6, 2003 By Will Richardson

    From the Nat’l Weather Service Alert for my county (via RSS by the way):

    ANY TRAVEL IS STRONGLY DISCOURAGED. IF YOU LEAVE THE SAFETY OF BEING
    INDOORS, YOU ARE PUTTING YOUR LIFE AT RISK.

    Ah, what the hell…they’re young…they’ll get over it.
    —–

    Filed Under: General, On My Mind

    Blogging is Work

    December 4, 2003 By Will Richardson

    Alan Levine observes that some significant voices in the edublogging sphere seem to be going quiet. He cites David Carter-Todd and David Davies, and I would have to add Sebastian Feidler, Pam Pritchard and Sarah Lohnes as three other voices I’ve been missing lately. Alan says:

    It appears, with some rough guestimation, that it takes about a year before a regular eduBlogger reaches the burn-out point…. which means I have about 3 months left in the gas gauge before I start to f-a-d-e away. Seriously, it calls into question how the practice of blogging will sustain, or is the norm that there will be waves of new passionate bloggers on the speed curve, and the waning decline of the seasoned writers? What will become of this litter of un-maintained blogs, proliferating Google-dom? Does it mean we get more echo blogging (direct regurgitation of news from elsewhere) and less original writing? What can it mean for educators who have high hopes of students keeping up a regular blog pace?

    These are great questions, no doubt, and relevant in many ways to my recent attempts to get a clearer grip on what we really have here. Notice that all the names mentioned above are writers who for the most part did more than just post links to interesting finds. They were “bloggers” in the sense that I defined it before. And in that sense, blogging requires effort and commitment, something that is in this screwed up, overwhelming time is certainly easy to lose. Fading away is not surprising. Original writing is work.

    Which is precisely why “blogging” is valuable. If it didn’t take effort, it wouldn’t be worth doing, worth learning from, and worth teaching. Linking is valuable, but it’s not hard. I don’t learn much from pointing to an interesting find. I do learn a lot, however, when I have to synthesize what I find and make it my own, and then spit it back out for an audience (real or perceived) that I hope will continue the process. I guess to me blogging is more the linking of thoughts than the links of, um, links.

    For educators, I’m not sure this has any huge implications. More and more I see this being accepted primarily as just (!) a tool. It’s going to take a very long time for enough people to recognize it as a valuable genre or form to teach writing and information literacy and analysis. And who knows, maybe no one ever will. I see Anne is trying to work her way through this with her “Wrinkles” group:

    We’re going to talk about all this and work on our new weblogs. Can’t wait! We may try to “tweak” Mr. Richardson’s writing a bit and have a model for elementary kids! Maybe we can create our own dynamic little community and who knows what all could evolve from such a good learning journey. Many say that it may not be possible and elementary students can’t do this. What do you think?

    It the “this” part that we’re all trying to define. What is it, in fact, that we’re trying to do? Maybe Web logs as tool (read: portal, online filing cabinet, collaborative space) is enough. I think once we work out some of the kinks, we’ll see a lot of people adopt the tool. But sustaining a Web log or teaching blogging as a valuable way to write…I just dunno.

    Filed Under: General, On My Mind

    It's Snowing…Wiki Wonderland

    December 1, 2003 By Will Richardson

    Between EdBlogger and the Thanksgiving break, I think my brain has gone into deep sleep mode. This morning was the first time in I don’t know how long that I really didn’t want to go to work or think about school or technology or Web logs. Everything feels kind of impermanent today; no focus, no urge to be productive, no real goal. It’s I’m watching the season’s inaugural snowfall, and that’s not helping. Gray and dusty. Windy. Yuck. Might be time for a brain break, but one quick glance at my todo list and I know that’s not likely to happen.

    We did some sprucing of blogs in class today. And I’m meeting with the newspaper kids on Thursday to see if we can’t get this thing cranked up on Friday. I actually started playing around with a Wiki site though I’m not sure how I’m going to use it, really. Would be cool if we kept class notes and ideas there; kind of like an online text that we all contribute to. But I can’t get a grip on it yet. Is it too much? What real worth will it have? What would they learn from wiki-ing? These are tough questions today…
    —–

    Filed Under: General, On My Mind

    I'm such a Geek…

    November 30, 2003 By Will Richardson

    …but not as much as many others. I only scored 134 on the MSNBC Geek Test. I’ve seen some scores over 190. Still, about five years ago I bet I would have scored about a 50 on a similar test for the times. Amazing how much I’ve learned in a short period of time.
    —–

    Filed Under: General, On My Mind

    Happy Thanksgiving

    November 27, 2003 By Will Richardson

    Tess, Tucker, Wendy, my home, good friends, Hunterdon County, food in the fridge, soy, a great job, cars that work, clothes in the closet, family, college buddies, the Cubs, sunrises, Anna Quindlen, a fireplace, heat, recycling, an Internet connection that works, Web logs and edbloggers, writing, Bill Moyers, 6-year old art, Amazon.com, the Delaware River, Hatteras, books, my students, online bill pay, nine years of not smoking, third straight Turkey Trot, Unitarian Universalism, clean air, well water, old photos, the loft, and the lingering hope that the many ills of the world will get better. Peace and good health.
    —–

    Filed Under: General, On My Mind

    Blogs Are Dead…Ouch

    November 23, 2003 By Will Richardson

    John Dvorak of PC Magazine skewers Web logs, and I mean skewers.

    Writing is tiresome. Why anyone would do it voluntarily on a blog mystifies a lot of professional writers. This is compounded by a lack of feedback, positive or otherwise. Perseus thinks that most blogs have an audience of about 12 readers. Leaflets posted on the corkboard at Albertsons attract a larger readership than many blogs. Some people must feel the futility. The problem is further compounded by professional writers who promote blogging, with the thought that they are increasing their own readership. It’s no coincidence that the most-read blogs are created by professional writers. They have essentially suckered thousands of newbies, mavens, and just plain folk into blogging, solely to get return links in the form of the blogrolls and citations. This is, in fact, a remarkably slick grassroots marketing scheme that is in many ways awesome, albeit insincere.

    Sheesh…it couldn’t be that he’s worried about his boring old print job, could it?

    Filed Under: General, On My Mind

    Tim's Ready for EdBlogger

    November 22, 2003 By Will Richardson

    It will be great to see Tim later today, and the fun has already started here in SF. Training with Bryan Bell today, reception tonight, discussions tomorrow. Here’s Tim’s pre-discussion thoughts:

    I’m accelerating toward putting the second version of our teacher’s hands on Friday, so I won’t have time to flesh out a few ideas I wanted to kick out before edBlogger on Sunday, so here’s a quick list of thoughts:
    When will the Salam Pax of the American urban public high school appear?
    And will he or she get a trip to the Ivy League for their trouble?
    Should we try to write a grant to fund an open source project to create the kind of content management system needed to do classroom blogging on a large scale?
    It may take tools designed for use in the Third World to solve the technological problems of inner-city schools.
    We should really avoid talking about our own blogs.
    If I start going off about OPML or RDF or any other obscure technical issue, send me to the time-out room.
    Overall, I have a really good feeling about this meeting.

    I agree…this shouldn’t be about our own spaces. These conversations should have one goal in mind, to advance our use of Web logs in the classroom and in schools. This will be the first time that we’ll have this size group of people in the same room all focused on education and schools. I’m feeling good about all of this too.

    By the way, Tim has started a blog for NCTE…

    Filed Under: General, On My Mind

    Too Much Fun–276 and Counting…

    November 20, 2003 By Will Richardson

    I think I’m having too much fun doing my daily post to my journalism class. First of all, it gives me a chance to be silly, but it also gives me a chance to point to really good work being done by my students. That was one major goal I had for this quarter was to be more Barbara Ganley and Anne Davis like in bringing together the relevant comments and work from among my students’ Web logs. It is just so very cool to be able to pull up their stuff and share it with the class, talk about why it’s exemplary, and give some real recognition to good stuff.

    Even better is that more of my teachers are starting to understand the power of the Web log portal. And this book discussion site that a group of teachers are working is really blossoming. (As is this one and this one!) We’re at over 275 Manila sites on our server right now, and while some of them aren’t getting a great deal of use, I’d say there are at least 150 active Web logs at our school. I’m finding now that when I go into classes to set kids up, there are at least one or two students that are Web log vets, and I’ve even run across a couple who have two sites going for two different classes at the same time. Warms my heart…

    I’m in a very happy place about all of this right now…perfect timing for EdBlogger!
    —–

    Filed Under: General, On My Mind

    What Makes Good Schools

    November 16, 2003 By Will Richardson

    The latest issue of Educational Leadership magazine is dedicated to accountability and devotes much of the issue to No Child Left Behind and it impact on schools. The articles are all very thought-provoking as they debate the best ways to deal with the expectations set by the law. Most of the authors argue that NCLB is unrealistic, based on bad philosophy, and more a burden than a help. The goals of the law are admirable, but the methods of implementing it are pretty out to lunch. It’s pretty heady stuff and worth tracking down if you don’t already get a copy.

    Anyway, there was one “a-ha” passage for me in an article by Richard Elmore titled “A Plea for Strong Practice.” Elmore enumerates the problems with the law and writes about more effective ways for schools to improve what they do. One key point that he makes is that “Knowledge is not necessarily where you think it is.” Basically, he says that there are a heckuva lot of “low performing” schools that know more about creating instructional improvement than other nominally high-performing schools. And in that section, he writes this:

    Most high-performing schools in our highly segregated society have gotten there not by knowing a great deal about instructional practice or improvement but by getting and holding on to students in high socioeconomic groups. The practice in most nominally high-performing schools is emphatically not about improvement but about maintenance of a certain level of confidence with the surrounding community.

    It made me think about my school, which for all intents and purposes is a great high school from most standpoints. But there’s no doubt that much of our success can be attributed to the fact that our kids come to us pretty successful to begin with. It’s almost like we just have to be careful not to screw them up. Now that’s not to say that we don’t have good teachers and good intentions to improve our practice. But we’re really not doing much that I would consider “bold” in terms of getting the most out of our kids. And I think all the posting of late about e-portfolios and alternative assessments has made that even more acute for me. It would be so cool if we were to push the envelope, challenge the assumptions more. But we’re so concerned, it seems, with doing well in the standardized areas that it leaves little room for real innovation. It’s too bad, not only for our kids but for the millions of kids across the country who are taught to pass the test without really knowing for sure they can put that knoweledge to productive practice.
    —–

    Filed Under: General, On My Mind

    ePortfolio White Paper

    November 14, 2003 By Will Richardson

    Another dip into the e-web-folio world with this study from ePortConsortium.org. Couple this with the post from yesterday and it’s pretty clear where this is heading, and I think I like it. There is much, much more than the blog-relevant excerpts I’ve pulled out below that is worthwhile reading, including a plethora of practical applications of such a program.

    Like a traditional portfolio, teachers, mentors, colleagues and friends can be invited to review and comment on work. Unlike traditional portfolios, participation is not limited to who can be physically present at any time or place. By organizing work to meet specific needs and managing access, the author can control the nature of the interaction. Teachers and mentors might exchange comments privately with the student/author about work in progress, colleagues and classmates might discuss their work with each other, the author might request feedback about specific issues and concerns, and students/authors can reflect on their learning experiences. In addition, work also can be made public for viewing and comments.

    and:

    The theory and value of portfolios has been more fully developed. Unlike paper-based portfolios, ePortfolios can more effectively provide both an authentic assessment of learning as well as significantly more information about the learning experience. The aim of the ePortfolio is to present and document the work and the process that the student and faculty member have used to get to a certain point. There is an ease of annotation that encourages dialogue. This evidence can then be saved and organized and reorganized to meet specific needs, such as relating the advising process to the student’s strengths and weaknesses, in order to make future learning experiences more relevant. Clearly, this is of great benefit to the academic dialogue that goes on throughout the student’s participation in the academy. It is then, that the true power of ePortfolio thinking begins to emerge.

    ePortfolios also can make it possible to include information, artifacts and reflection on more than just the courses that a student takes. They can be used to capture learning experiences that usually fall between the cracks — that do not result from a specific class, but are gained from social interactions, extracurricular activities, internships and other less formal learning opportunities. The desired outcome is that when a student finally uses the portfolio as a tool to seek employment or advance study opportunities, the whole will be greater than the sum of the parts.

    BTW, Tom’s response to my earlier post has me thinking too…
    —–

    Filed Under: General, On My Mind

    A Long Way to Go

    November 10, 2003 By Will Richardson

    Back in the classroom today for the first time in about six months, and it was something I was really looking forward to. I really like adolescents; for all of their struggles and issues and pressures, I find them usually to be the most interesting people I meet in any given day. All that uncertainty and angst…

    But I have to tell you, if the state of the world rests with our youth, we might be in trouble. Not that these kids aren’t basically good humans whose hearts are in the right place…the vast majority of students at my school are pretty solid, typical upper-middle class suburban kids. But I always get a bit scared when I ask what I think are some basic questions that citizens in a participatory democracy like ours should know, like naming two Supreme Court justices, for example. Twenty kids, three of them raised their hands. Or like naming two of the Democratic candidates for president…one hand. Only a few of them know who Jessica Lynch was (I asked ’cause this is her big week in the news.) And this at a school that ranks very highly in SAT and state test scores (which ought to tell you how much they’re worth…) I doubt any of them could have named a story on the cover of the New York Times. From someone who thrives on information, who believes that it’s our duty to be active in the democratic process, it’s pretty disheartening. I know they’re young, but 14 of ’em are going to be old enough to vote next year. We’ll have enough voting age kids at our school next year to have turned the election in Florida last time around. Just our school.

    And who is to blame? Is it the school? Probably to some extent. We don’t do a great job, I don’t think, of making sure kids leave here with the minimum basic skills to participate. I forget who I heard it from, but someone labeled ours an “Attention Deficit Democracy.” It’s true, and I think we cater to it in many ways by not requiring media and information literacy skills (Canada does it,) basic environmental living (you should see what ends up in our trash cans,) and community service. I know, I know. I’m dreaming. But we’re so beholden to test scores and college acceptances that there’s no focus on what’s truly important. Especially in this complex, scary world, our kids need more awareness of their responsibilities as citizens of the planet. (If you don’t believe me, read Dave Pollard from time to time.)

    Is it the parents? Well, most of them could use some of those same skills, I think. Here’s a typical response to the first homework assignment where I asked them to describe the news gathering process in their homes…

    No, keeping up with news going on in the world isn’t that important to my family. We try to keep up on news but our household is so busy that its tough to keep up on news. Our family normally gets our news from the t.v.(msnbc) and the newspaper(Star Ledger). Our family normally watches the news 3 to 4 times a week and reads the saturday and sunday paper. My dad is the most news literate in my family. He is on the computer during work checking the news and he always listens to the radio to see what is going on. I am not that news literate. It just really isn’t that important to me. Yes i do watch the news sometimes but i don’t show a great interest in it.

    My own kids would be embarrassed to answer that question. They’d say their parents are nuts, that they have C-Span on for background noise, that they read books and magazines and newspapers constantly, and that most of the conversations they have (aside from whose turn it is to do the laundry) are about politics or news or the state of the world. (And that their father is an Internet addict who spends far too much time “aggregating” the news…)

    So here I come, riding in on my Web log horse, starry-eyed and dreaming that they’ll get it, that they’ll understand why writing readers will save the world, and that they’ll feel empowered to be a part of the process. And 15 minutes later I’m staring into the abyss, chuckling, determined to give it my best shot, but really depressed that these kids aren’t more engaged, more passionate about what’s happening around them. When all you do is read impassioned, inspired reader writers, it’s easy to lose perspective, I guess. I gotta remember small victories are just as important as sea change.
    —–

    Filed Under: General, On My Mind

    Web Log Lesson Plans

    November 8, 2003 By Will Richardson

    I got an e-mail today from a teacher in Virginia asking if I knew any examples of lesson plans that included Web logs. I started thinking if I had any specific plans written down about how I introduced and implemented Web logs in my classes and I quickly came to the realization that this site is about as close to a Web log lesson plan as I can get. This teacher is new to Web logging and wants to introduce them as part of an English project. I know there are some out there, but are there any other formal Web logging inclusive lesson plans to share?
    —–

    Filed Under: General, On My Mind

    • « Previous Page
    • 1
    • …
    • 41
    • 42
    • 43
    • 44
    • 45
    • Next Page »

    Recent Posts

    • “Never”
    • My 2023 “Tech Cleanse” Has Begun
    • Five Themes for Educators in 2023
    • Schools in a Time of Chaos
    • Has This Crisis Really Changed Schools?

    Search My Blog

    Archived Posts

    Copyright © 2026 Will Richardson · All Rights Reserved

    Follow me on Twitter @willrich45