Will Richardson

Speaker, consultant, writer, learner, parent

  • About
    • About Will
    • Testimonials
    • Contact Will
  • Blog
  • Speaking
  • Coaching
  • Books
  • BQI

The “Khanification” of Education

October 20, 2012 By Will Richardson

Yesterday I Tweeted out a link to a video titled “Meet the YouTube Next EDU Gurus,” a video that I found disconcerting on a number of levels, (not the least of which the music.) I know that in one way, the subjects of the video exemplify the participation, transparency, and, at times, creativity that I actually hope my kids aspire to. But what bothered me is that we seem to have reached a “Khanification” of education moment where anyone with a passion can make a video and be given “teacher” status. A moment captured by this Michael Schnieder Tweet back to me:

Which begs the questions, a) what should an education degree or a teaching certificate  require when increasingly anyone with a connection can be a teacher of content, and, b) more importantly, what changes when the world begins to accept a definition of “teacher” as someone who knows “how to make and post a video”? (Read the comments below the vid.)

In many ways, I’ve been pushed by Sal Khan’s lack of teaching experience more than by his videos. But now this growing acceptance of non-teachers as teachers of content and skills  (and, in some cases, better teachers of content and skills) poses an ever greater challenge for us to redefine the profession. And it circles back around to that question that I pose in the book: what is our value as classroom teachers in a world suddenly filled with teachers?

Here’s a hint: our value lies in that which cannot be Khanified. We better figure out ways pretty quickly to articulate that value in spades to parents, boards, corporations, etc. 

UPDATE: Related

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: education, learning, sal khan, shifts, teaching, whyschool

I Want a Meta Learning App

October 17, 2012 By Will Richardson

Every time I click my browser history in Chrome (usually when I’m looking for some webpage that I found yesterday but seems to have vanished from my tabs,) I always find myself taking a couple minutes to stare in wonder at how many Web clicks I make in a day. Not sure why, but I almost always find it fascinating to scan through the places I’ve been, the time I spent there, how random much of it is, and how focused other segments of it are. It’s an interesting but incomplete picture of my brain on the Web.

So I’ve been thinking, I want an app that captures everything I do not just on the Web but on the entire computer and then dives into that data to give me a quick daily snapshot of my learning work. In some detail, I want it to:

  • List the most visited websites and minutes spent there.
  • List the most used tools (Chrome, Evernote, Tweet Deck, Keynote, etc.) and active time in those tools (as opposed to just time open or running in the background.)
  • Total number of clicks.
  • Total number of switches between programs.
  • Total number of interactions with others (e-mails sent, Tweets, comments, Skype calls) with names or handles of those people.
  • Some type of focus or attention analysis, as in was there a period of the day that my work seemed most “on task” however that might be defined.
  • For each of these areas, I want trending arrows (green for up, red for down) that compare my activities for that day to the previous week and entire history of the app.
  • Number of words typed.
  • List of web pages that were Evernoted, Tweeted, or saved in some way. (It would be icing to see how those notes or Tweets were interacted with as well.
  • And a whole bunch of other stuff that I’m hoping you’ll suggest in the comments.

Why would I want this? Because it would help me understand myself more deeply as a learner with technology. I’ve really been swayed by the thinking of Howard Rheingold and others about our need to understand attention and focus in these spaces, and a quick look at just my browsing history shows I’m not the most focused learner at times. I know that Cathy Davidson has argued that this may be the natural state of things, and it’s not like what needs to get done isn’t getting done. But I do think that we are going to have to learn to be more mindful of our practice, and an app like this could help me, at least, do just that. 

Thoughts?

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: apps, data, education, learning, meta

Important, Intriguing, Beautiful Questions

October 13, 2012 By Will Richardson

Ken Bain:

People are most likely to take a deep approach to their learning when they are trying to answer questions or solve problems that they have come to regard as important, intriguing, or just beautiful. One of the great secrets to fostering deep learning is the ability to help students raise new kinds of questions that they will find fascinating. Sometimes that means beginning with the questions that are already on their minds and helping them see how those inquiries lead to new puzzles.

I love this. And I love the idea that we can allow students (and ourselves) to find beauty in questions. That we should foster that. I mean really, how many beautiful questions did you explore in your education. How many that came from our own hearts? How cool would school have been if there had been more of that?

I look at my own kids and know this: up until this point, their teachers have supplied almost every question they are to find an answer to. (This is changing as next year they’ll both be attending my old high school where inquiry based learning is taking root.) My kids have by and large lost much of their desire to question other than to clarify whatever it is they are supposed to learn. And I know this, too: much of that is my own fault. (When do I get to play the “parenting do-over card”?)

In the context of questions, schools need a reframing. (Can you imagine an exit test where kids ASK the questions instead of answer them?) Bain articulates an interesting shift:

One secret might be in reframing the very nature of education. We often “sell” education as the chance to learn some subjects—chemistry, history, philosophy, business, whatever. In my new book, I explore a different kind of education in which students think of their experience in school as that chance to expand their own capacities and pursue intriguing and important questions and problems. Education can help people become more creative and productive individuals. At the heart of that approach is the realization that every student brings to each question a unique perspective that can be explored and expanded. 

And finally this. What is the purpose of school for kids? Is it learning? Really?

The problem that often arises is that we strip people of any sense of purpose. We give them assignments to do rather than stimulate their curiosity with fascinating questions that provoke and challenge. We hold them responsible to a rigid code of conduct rather than helping them to grow. We say to them, I’ve got a mold, and I’m going to fit you into that mold, and if you don’t fit, I’ll trim something off around the edges. We should be saying: what are your questions, what is your background, have you considered this possibility, have you explored this avenue?

Yes, we should.

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: education, learning, schools

“I’ve Always Done Worksheets”

October 12, 2012 By Will Richardson

A couple of weeks ago, Wendy and Tucker and I went to Maker Faire in New York City and it was, in a word, incredible. I’m not much of a maker myself, and I’ll admit being a bit late to the whole concept that seems to be exploding right now, but I was just amazed at how much cool stuff people were building and sharing. Brain. Melt. (On a side note, we’re going to be visiting this weekend with a local professor who has been using Arduino in his classrooms and promises to get us up to speed.) 

Right after that, I had the chance to stop by TechShop Detroit where I got a tour of what I can only describe as a builder’s paradise…3D printers and CAD computers and wood fabricators and water saws and…you get the idea. Stuff that used to be fringy in high school now going mainstream. 

And then, this morning, I ran across this: WikiSeat. And I’m thinking, “every child a maker.” Here’s someone who has created a “catalyst” or a basic starter piece for seat design, an easy entry into the maker idea, and an English teacher who has run with it. Not high tech, but high thinking. And the learning payoff is amazing. And I love the kids:

“I’ve never really done anything that’s like construction. I’ve always done worksheets and tests. It was probably the best test I’ve ever done in my life…It really just made me feel like I can complete any assignment that I want to do. I used to like didn’t want to do assignments because they felt too difficult, and after that, nothing feels difficult anymore.”

And the teacher, Sean Wheeler:

“We spend a lot of time putting kids in front of geniuses telling them to study genius in other people. But what you’re really doing in teaching this project is pulling genius out of kids. Instead of trying to force it into them.”

All of which speaks to this idea that we may be at the precipice of a real explosion of creative entrepreneurism that will be built on self-direction and resilience and failure and innovation and collaboration…none of which we truly value in the current school system enough to significantly change our approach. Nothing that Race to the Top wants to pay us for. (Wired’s Chris Anderson has a new book that dives into this idea: Makers:The New Industrial Revolution.)

So here’s the deal. If you’re a classroom teacher, you have until October 18 at noon to let the folks at WikiSeat know that you want to participate in a huge seat-making, problem solving, genius pulling project on a national scale. Provided their Kickstarter funding comes through, they’ll provide you all the “catalysts” you need by spring break 2013 to get your kids imagining and innovating and making.

Oh, and you can do it too.

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: education, learning, maker, wikiseat

The CCSS “Open Question”

October 11, 2012 By Will Richardson

William Mathis

Regarding the two national assessment consortia, the nature and use of the assessments will be crucial. Mathis expresses concern, noting that No Child Left Behind resulted in high-stakes testing that narrowed and “dumbed down” the curriculum and often resulted in test-driven drill and practice. Whether the testing consortia have the financial resources to implement high-quality and higher-order assessments on time is also an open question. [Emphasis mine.]

Whatever you think about the CCSS, that last part is the key. And it’s not just the financial resources; I can’t imagine given the amount of time we’re going to spend testing that at some point people aren’t going to stand up and say “Enough!" 

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: ccss, education, learning

“These Pills are Your Grades”

October 9, 2012 By Will Richardson

Stunning.

The Doctor:

Although A.D.H.D is the diagnosis Dr. Anderson makes, he calls the disorder “made up” and “an excuse” to prescribe the pills to treat what he considers the children’s true ill — poor academic performance in inadequate schools.

“I don’t have a whole lot of choice,” said Dr. Anderson, a pediatrician for many poor families in Cherokee County, north of Atlanta. “We’ve decided as a society that it’s too expensive to modify the kid’s environment. So we have to modify the kid.”

The Parent:

“My kids don’t want to take it, but I told them, ‘These are your grades when you’re taking it, this is when you don’t,’ and they understood,” Ms. Williams said.

The Educator

The superintendent of one major school district in California, who spoke on the condition of anonymity, noted that diagnosis rates of A.D.H.D. have risen as sharply as school funding has declined.

 “It’s scary to think that this is what we’ve come to; how not funding public education to meet the needs of all kids has led to this,” said the superintendent, referring to the use of stimulants in children without classic A.D.H.D. “I don’t know, but it could be happening right here. Maybe not as knowingly, but it could be a consequence of a doctor who sees a kid failing in overcrowded classes with 42 other kids and the frustrated parents asking what they can do. The doctor says, ‘Maybe it’s A.D.H.D., let’s give this a try.’"

Cheap and easy wins the day…again.

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: education, learning, schools

The New Entrepreneurial Class

October 8, 2012 By Will Richardson

Robert Safian:

For all the concerns they cite about the plight of small business, from tax burdens to health care costs and so on, what pols of all stripes are missing is that America is experiencing a wave of entrepreneurialism unlike anything we’ve ever had before. Inspired by the likes of Mark Zuckerberg at Facebook, by the incredible success of Steve Jobs and Apple, by nimble new industrial designers, by the myriad app-makers and startups populating Silicon Valley, Silicon Alley, and every place in between, a generation of people–young and old–are enthusiastically and optimistically setting out to build new businesses and to invent new ways of doing business. Some of them tap into new platforms like Kickstarter, Etsy, and Indiegogo. Some tap into incubators like TechStars and Y Combinator. Sometimes these entrepreneurs are moonlighting, sometimes they work within huge corporations, and sometimes, yes, they are in a garage or a coffee house or a co-working space. But that doesn’t make this phenomenon any less real.

Wendy and I were talking the other night about the fact that very, very few of our friends are working for anyone other than themselves. It was kind of shocking when we started going through the list. Cabinetmakers, consultants, marketers, designers, app makers…the list goes on. I can’t remember the last person who came to our house with a real 9-5-ish job. 

Wondering, as always, what it will be like for my kids…

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: education, entrepreneurs, learning, shift

What is the “Sound Foundation”?

October 6, 2012 By Will Richardson

From Abundance by Peter Diamandis:

…We’re training our children in skills they rarely need, while ignoring those they absolutely do. Teaching kids how to nourish their creativity and curiosity, while still providing a sound foundation in critical thinking, literacy and math, is the best way to prepare them for a future of increasingly rapid technological change (Kindle 471).

I’ve been having some interesting conversations lately with people who are basically like “ok, if we can learn almost anything on our own, then what do we really need to teach in school?” Not a new question, I know, but cropping up more and more it seems of late. 

I know there are some who are curriculum minimalists somewhere just to the right of Summerhill, and others who think the sound foundation of literacy and math is so encompassing that it can only be achieved through proscribed curricula and teaching to until a student is nearing adulthood. (Pearson loves the latter view, no doubt.)

My view is that we are teaching EVERY child way too much stuff, that EVERY child does not need nearly as much math or science or literature or history as we seem to think, and I believe that EVERY child loses a fair amount of creativity and curiosity in our zeal to deliver and test the all encompassing curriculum. And we do this because we think school is the only place to easily learn all that stuff, or because that’s what “college readiness” is. And in our subject-based world, everyone will fight to the death against eliminating any of it. 

But at what cost?

Last I looked, not even a third of adults in the US have a college degree. I’d be surprised if 10% of adults over 30 could pass the current state graduation tests that all of our kids have to take. That’s not because they’re stupid, but because they’ve long forgotten the parts of the curriculum that didn’t end up being relevant to their real lives. 

So I wonder, what, really, does EVERY child need to know? What defines a “sound foundation” that EVERY child can build upon down whatever chosen road they take for their learning? 

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: education, learning

Let’s Make it an Even 300, OK?

September 24, 2012 By Will Richardson

Been doing some ciphering as to the number of state or national tests New Jersey kids starting kindergarten next year will be taking through their school careers:

  • Four PARCC tests a year grades two through 12=44
  • Under the NJ Model Curriculum, five assessments a year, K-12 in English=65
  • Under the  NJ Model Curriculum, five assessments a year, K-11 in Math=60
  • (Coming Soon) Under the  NJ Model Curriculum, five assessments a year, K-12 in Social Studies=65
  • (Coming Soon) Under the  NJ Model Curriculum, five assessments a year, K-12 in Science=65
  • Yet to be determined K-12 assessments in Visual and Performing Arts, World Languages, PE/Health under the NJ Model Curriculum=??????????

Total known state and national tests in 12 years of school: 299

Really.

Some questions come to mind:

  • Does anyone think this is good for kids?
  • Does anyone not think this will increase focus on test prep?
  • Does anyone not think this will decrease a teacher’s ability to provide rich learning experiences for kids?
  • Do the standards and model curriculum attempt to prepare kids for the “new normal” of the world as it is?
  • Who are these people? 

That’s just a start.

Yours? 

UPDATE: I realized I was a bit off on the number. Really it’s at least 214. Social Studies and Science will only be tested during high school according to the NJ Model Curriculum. Still…

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: education, learning, not, reform, testing

Another Stunningly Bad Vision for Learning

September 23, 2012 By Will Richardson

From the somewhat ironically titled Getting Smart blog:

Harun envisions ShowMe playing a role in the future classroom. “Maybe we will shift to a new form of classrooms, leaving the traditional way of gathering 20-30 students in a room everyday,” said Harun. “Maybe students will have their own cubicles as we do now, and they will run apps and watch videos, etc. Or maybe they will not have the obligation to come to school everyday, they will study at home, with their parents working at home.”

Ok, so here we go again. This is what “learning” looks like to folks who think an education is simply mastering a set of concepts and skills that we deliver to kids. We know what they need to know, and all that we really need to change is the delivery method. Cubicles and apps. That’s reform. Cheaper. More efficient. Quantifiable.

Check. The. Box.

Anyone else have a problem with that? 

And on another note, I’ve been thinking lately that there’s a whole ‘nother level of problem with the “personalized learning” term. You can’t really personalize learning can you? You can personalize content with the aim that students will learn something. But the learning isn’t fait accompli.

Personal learning is just that. Personalized? #notsomuch

Thoughts?

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: education, learning, teaching

Schools vs. Abundance

September 20, 2012 By Will Richardson

I ran across this graphic in a Chris Anderson Wired article from a few years ago, and with a bit of editing, I think it speaks to the dissonance between school (scarcity) and not school (abundance) that I tried to capture in Why School? 

At the district, school, classroom, teacher, and student level, this is a hugely complex shift to navigate. 

Wondering which of those categories to the left you’re finding most difficult to come to terms with and what strategies you have for dealing with them.

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: change, chris anderson, education, learning, schools, teaching

Our Numbers Obsession Will Kill Us

September 19, 2012 By Will Richardson

It’s been an assessment oriented day here on the ol’ blog.

From the Boston Globe:

But if Shaffer and other next-generation test designers share a dream of replacing pen-and-paper exams with process-oriented problem-solving exercises, they also share a thorny challenge: The skills they’re trying to measure are much harder to detect and quantify than, say, whether someone knows the quadratic formula. “It’s not just that [complex skills] are harder to isolate—it’s that they don’t exist in isolation,” said Shaffer.

Breaking down these multifaceted skills into testable qualities is difficult, and it’s something educators have been trying and failing to do for more than half a century. The first president of ETS, which has long administered the SAT, set out in 1948 to develop a test that could evaluate a student’s intellectual stamina, ability to get along with others, and so on—but the company eventually concluded it was too hard to measure in a reliable way. More recently, in the late 1980s and ’90s, the Harvard developmental psychologist Howard Gardner participated in an effort to design new kinds of tests in the humanities that could be graded objectively. Ultimately, he found that the nuance required to measure softer skills collided with the demands of standardization. When a test needs to reliably compare students from across schools and districts, “there is pressure to simplify, have ironclad rubrics, essentially move toward multiple choice,” Gardner wrote in an e-mail.

And there you have it. “The nuance required to measure softer skills collided with the demands of standardization.” And god knows we need to standardize because if we don’t, how in the heck are we going to rank kids, evaluate teacher effectiveness, give letter grades to schools, assess teacher preservice programs, and beat Finland?

Here’s the thing: You may think the Common Core is more about critical thinking and skills than about content, a move in the right direction, but it doesn’t matter. The assessments will HAVE TO BE about the quantifiable, since we’ve done such a good job at raising the stakes around how the results will be used.

We’re borked.

According to the late Gerald Bracey, who conducted extensive research and authored numerous books about the misuse of data on education among policymakers, politicians, and the media, a measure of some of the most valuable achievements that test results cannot capture include: creativity, critical thinking, resilience, motivation, persistence, curiosity, endurance, reliability, enthusiasm, self-discipline, leadership, resourcefulness, and a sense of wonder [Emphasis mine].

The immeasurable. 

James Paul Gee:

“[Historically], the testing industry, because it was pragmatic, only tested what it was easy to test. But as a parent, I don’t want you to just test what’s easy to test, I want you to test what’s important to test.”

Sadly, that ain’t gonna happen. 

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: assessment, education, learning, schools

On Assessment and Measurement

September 19, 2012 By Will Richardson

Alfie Kohn:

In education, the question “How do we assess kids/teachers/schools?” has morphed over the years into “How do we measure … ?” We’ve forgotten that assessment doesn’t require measurement, and, moreover, that the most valuable forms of assessment are often qualitative (say, a narrative account of a child’s progress by an observant teacher who knows the child well), rather than quantitative (a standardized-test score). Yet the former may well be brushed aside in favor of the latter by people who don’t even bother to ask what was on the test. It’s a number, so we sit up and pay attention. Over time, the more data we accumulate, the less we really know.

Amen.

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: alfie kohn, assessment, education, learning

What the Web Does and Does Not Scale

September 18, 2012 By Will Richardson

George Siemens writing in a new blog that he’s sharing with Dave Cormier and Bonnie Stewart as they craft a new book about the future of higher education:

Our thesis with xEducation is that the internet is happening to higher education and that successful universities of the future will be those that find ways to generate value for its many stakeholders that go beyond content provision and teaching. What exactly that value proposition is remains unclear. On the one hand, content and (recorded) lectures can easily be shared with limited costs. The internet scales content exceptionally well. The human, social, processes of learning don’t scale. Research doesn’t scale (yet). Regional and national economic value generation doesn’t scale. In these spaces where scalability does not work well, universities will likely find their new roles in society. Over the next six months, we’ll explore and test this thesis and place the discussion of higher education reform on a firmer foundation than the latest tool and popular hype [Emphasis mine].

When we ask the question “Why School?” or “what is our value when content and teachers are everywhere?” the answer rests in that human, social process. And I think this is a function of K-12 as much if not more than higher ed. If our focus is not in developing learners through the face to face nudging, modeling, questioning, feedback that stems from our human selves, that stuff that technology, to date at least, has not been able to provide, then I think we run the risk of irrelevance. 

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: education, learning, teaching

This is “Student” Learning?

September 17, 2012 By Will Richardson

So this may be (pdf) the most convoluted definition of student learning that I’ve seen yet. From the Indiana DOE’s RISE teacher evaluation system:

Student learning is a teacher’s contribution to academic progress over the course of the school year.

Come again? It’s the teacher’s contribution? And just in terms of academic progress?

Wow.

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: education, Indiana, learning, teaching

“Agreeing” on Student Achievement

September 17, 2012 By Will Richardson

From today’s New York Times:

The Chicago teachers’ strike was prompted in part by a fierce disagreement over how much student test scores will weigh in a new teacher evaluation system mandated by state law. That teachers’ unions in much of the country now agree that student achievement should count in evaluations at all reflects a major change from the past, when it was often argued that teaching was an “art” that could not be rigorously evaluated or, even more outrageously, that teachers should not be held accountable for student progress.

A couple of quick points.

1. One could argue that “unions in much of the country now agree” because they were strong armed into doing so by Race to the Top bribes of stimulus money to states who accepted these new teacher evaluation systems. Fighting it was a no win for the unions which have been the target of intense and focused attacks over the last few years. 

2. No one ever argued that teachers should not be held accountable for student progress. 

3. Most importantly, think about this piece: “unions in much of the country now agree that student achievement should count in evaluations.” Since it’s so obviously clear that “student achievement” only comes in the guise of test scores, I guess the rest of what accounts for learning doesn’t matter much.

One of my goal in the coming months is to keep being the rhetoric police when it comes to the way the mainstream media talks about this stuff. 

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: education, learning, schools, teachers

Why School?

September 13, 2012 By Will Richardson

It’s with a great deal of excitement and bit of trepidation that I share my newest book, published by TED Books. It’s a 14,000-word e-book only, extended essay in which I try to flesh out the ideas I’ve been speaking and writing about lately, most recently at this TEDx Talk in Melbourne from this summer. 

I’m excited because it’s an opportunity, I hope, to spread a different conversation around what schools can be and, I think, need to be at this moment when our access to information and teachers and a whole bunch of other stuff is exploding. I sincerely believe that over the next couple of decades, what happens in schools is going to fundamentally change, and that there are basically two competing narratives around what that change looks like. Right now, the not so wonderful narrative is taking hold. I’m humbly hoping that Why School? can in some way serve as a support for the other more student-centered narrative to take hold.

My trepidation stems from my knowledge that this is not a perfect book, that like everything else that I write, it’s a push of my own thinking. I’m sure there are points that will deserve pushback here. I’m hoping it’s civil. ;0)

I’m loathe to overstate things, but I’m becoming more and more convinced that this is a crucially important moment in the history of schools. I’m constantly reminded of a quote a read a few years ago from Cathy Davidson and David Goldberg:

The future of conventional learning institutions is past – it’s over – unless those directing the course of our learning institutions realize, now and urgently, the necessity of fundamental and foundational change.

Hoping that in some way, this effort advances that conversation. 

As always, would love you to share your thoughts, good and bad. Thanks for reading.

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: education, learning, whyschool

The Thin Value Proposition

August 29, 2012 By Will Richardson

I think Chris really nails it here:

For-profit education assumes a thin value proposition of the promise of educational technology, using these tools as a way to automate and teacher-proof teaching while having the effect of creating a more standardized curriculum (which will most likely be tied to a standardized assessment) that may allow students more ability to proceed at their own pace but will, in the end, be more restrictive in terms of student ownership over their own learning. That is a profound failure of the promise of educational technology.

It’s becoming more and more apparent in my travels that what teachers and administrators all over the place are feeling is a continued narrowing of student outcomes to those things that are easily measured which can then be used to evaluate anything and everything about schools. The idea that there is any real concern about “student ownership over their own learning” on the part of policy makers or for-profit planners is becoming laughable on its face.

But here’s the thing: a few days ago I listened to two rising seniors in high school welcome back their teachers at an opening day with two very moving, articulate speeches. They talked with emotion about the teachers who they will never forget, the bus drivers who eased their transitions to school, the administrators who have guided them at important points in their lives. They never once talked about how well prepared they felt for the test. Never once did they suggest that the most important things they are taking with them from high school are grades or content knowledge or problem solving skills, all of which are no doubt a part of the equation for “success.” The value of school they spoke about came directly from the relationships, the encouragement, the patience, the nudging, the inspiration that came from the adults in the room, all of which will serve them to a greater degree than than passing the test.

That’s what we will lose if we see technology only as a way to “automate and teacher-proof teaching,” if we envision it like some as a low-cost way to deliver the curriculum to get better scores and “higher student achievement.” That’s a deeply scary scenario.

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: education, learning, schools

The Learners We Need

August 16, 2012 By Will Richardson

So, the whole MOOC thing has been on my brain of late for a variety of reasons…the Coursera announcement, the  figuring out of which of the many MOOC-ish variations is really a MOOC, and the implications of all of it (if any) for the K-12 set. Let me just say at the outset that I’m most interested in the Canadian style MOOC (a la Siemens, Downes, Cormier, Couros, et al.) which fully puts the onus of learning on the learner and the community of learners that form around the topic. As opposed to the Coursera model, there aren’t any canned videos being flipped, just big questions and interactions among the participants attempting to answer them.

What interests me is what qualities it takes to be successful in a true MOOC environment, and what qualities it takes to be a successful self-directed, more-or-less informal learner online in general. To that end, Peter Gow has an interesting reflection on his experience in the MOOCMOOC class that is looking at the MOOC experience as learners experience it. (Meta, I know.) . As Peter says, the learner is in charge:

The MOOC MOOC is all about “connectivist” learning—a model that puts a considerable burden on the “learner” for figuring out what’s going on and for developing the skills and tools for using all the amorphousness of the cloud and a wealth of social media to bring a connected structure—it’s sort of pattern recognition, sort of gestalt—to the learning process…

But that takes some qualities that we don’t cultivate very well, imho, in the current education systems we put our kids in. Here’s Peter’s shortlist of requirements for success:

Genuine interest. I have to care enough about the course material to wrestle with the big ideas and small details—and the homework—all on my own. If I don’t actually care that much about what I am supposed to be learning, each task becomes drudgery. Without this, the rest is irrelevant.

A certain amount of online extrovertedness and confidence. I’ve got to be able to jump into conversations, offer critical analysis and even critique, in multiple online media. The inherent risks in online commentary—that my dry sense of humor won’t be understood and that we’ll all just say nice things to get our participation “checked off” with no troubling downside—are all present, and I’m working on this.

Comfort with the medium. This may mean downloading, installing, configuring, and learning how to use new software or new online tools. Fortunately I’m more or less okay here, although I’m not ready to code, which seems not to be even a possibility.

Dedicated time. This is not a pop-in, pop-out activity; I need to clear a bunch of time to get through each element of the work. This is more of a challenge than it should be, given the time of year, but it’s not insurmountable—where there’s a will there’s a way (see #1 above).

It’s actually that second one that has me thinking more than the rest. It begs the question “Can kids, or adults for that matter, who are not disposed to transparency and interactions in public social spaces be expected to succeed in the types of learning opportunities that MOOCs offer?” And, further, if we find that quality to have significant value in a person’s learning life, is that something we can help students cultivate in our K-12 schools?

I don’t think anyone knows exactly how this all plays out, but is it fair to say that if we’re not shifting our emphasis to helping kids develop as learners who can take advantage of these informal (perhaps soon to be accredited) learning experiences, we’re shortchanging them? 

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: dispositions, education, learning, mooc

The Local Internet School

August 11, 2012 By Will Richardson

Don’t say I didn’t warn you.

Yale professor David Gelernter in the Wall Street Journal, lengthy but important:

A local Internet school sounds like a contradiction in terms: the Internet lets you discard geography and forget “local.” But the idea is simple. A one-classroom school, with 20 or so children of all ages between 6th and 12th grade, each sitting at a computer and wearing headsets. They all come from nearby. A one-room Internet school might serve a few blocks in a suburb, or a single urban apartment building.

In front sits any reliable adult whom the neighbors vouch for—often, no doubt, some student’s father or mother, taking his turn. He leads the Pledge of Allegiance, announces regular short recesses to clear everyone’s head, proclaims lunchtime. He hands out batteries and Band-Aids and sends sick children home or to a doctor. He reloads the printers and futzes with malfunctioning scanners, no doubt making any problem worse. But these machines are cheap, and each classroom can deploy several.

Each child does a whole curriculum’s worth of learning online, at the computer. Most of the time he follows canned courses on-screen. But for an hour every day, he deals directly, one-to-one over phone or videophone with a tutor. Ideally there’s a teaching assistant on an open phone line throughout the day, each assistant dealing with a few dozen students. In early years, parents will need to help here too. And each child needs a mentor who advises parents on courses and keeps track of the student’s progress. The wealthy conservative foundation, think tank or consortium that spends liberally to get this idea off the ground will probably provide mentors, in early years, from its own staff.

The online courses—some exist already but not enough—are produced by teaching maestros. As these new schools gather momentum, they will make use, as tutors or assistants, of the huge number of people who are willing and able to help children in some topic for a few hours a week but can’t or won’t teach full time: college and graduate students and retirees, lawyers, accountants, housewives, professors.

Parents must be far more involved in children’s educations than most are today. They must choose—with online help and advice from mentors and friends—a set of courses for each child every year. They must talk to their children about school every day, to make sure things are moving forward. They might need to take turns supervising the class. A few will have taken the hugely time-consuming step of organizing the school to begin with.

Obviously these schools aren’t for everyone. But for many thousands of students, they are likely to work well—and better every year, as the pool of courseware, tutors and assistants grows.

And that vision isn’t the most troubling part. Read the comments.

I’ll say it again: The key question we need to be asking AND answering is “What value do schools have in a world where technology can deliver the traditional curriculum and raise standardized test scores "better” than teachers can?“ Even if that last part is just perception. 

If we can’t answer that question compellingly, we’re toast. 

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: education, learning, technology

The “Immeasurable” Part 2

August 3, 2012 By Will Richardson

I’ve been thinking about ways to represent the emphasis on the measurable that I wrote about a few weeks ago, and I’ve come up with this graph which, I think, comes close to capturing the problem right now. 

What I’m trying to get at is that our school assessment lives primarily in the bottom left part of that graph, and that we rarely if ever get to the “immeasurable” stuff that resides toward the top right. To put it another way, we focus in schools on that which is quantifiable when, I think, our real value as places of learning rests in that messy stuff that isn’t.

What do you think? Am I capturing something worth capturing here? Am I missing something? 

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: assessment, education, learning, schools, teaching, technology

Invented Things

August 1, 2012 By Will Richardson

Cathy Davidson:

Here’s a list (in no particular order) of some of the changes in U.S. education, from kindergarten to professional school, either invented or finalized in the Taylorist era (the same era that produced the assembly line, statistics, standard deviation, spreadsheets, blueprints, punch clocks): mandatory public secondary schooling, research universities, majors, minors, divisions, certification, graduate school, collegiate law school, nursing school, graduate school of education, collegiate business school, degree requirements, grades, required courses, electives, distribution requirements, IQ tests, multiple choice tests, item response college entrance exams (SAT), school rankings, class rankings. And learning disabilities.

There are some great things in that list. My point in this open-ended meditation, though, is that these are invented things. Like all inventions, they are historically situated, created for a specific time and place, to solve problems of an era and address the possibilities afforded by the society, institutions, wealth, ambitions, and technologies of that time and place. Like statistics and the assembly line, the system of education we have inherited is not “timeless.” It is an industrial age invention. So is the practice of ranking students from best to worst (“one best way”), using standardized forms of testing (extending Galton’s questionnaire form to the one-best-answer or item-response test).

We invented these standardized, regulatory, categorizing, statistical, practices for determining educational success or failure for the Fordist era of the assembly line. We can invent better ones for our own era.

So, I’m stealing this line: “The system of education we have inherited is not timeless.” I’ve been asking audiences lately what did we do before we had this thing called school? How did we learn? How were we graded? It’s not a great conversation starter. I think most have such little context for anything different that it’s almost impossible to see beyond the structures we’ve built. It echoes, once again, Tom Carroll’s astute question over a decade ago:

If we didn’t have the schools we have today, would we create the schools we have today?

Um…no.

(BTW, Clay Shirky instigated a similar discussion about higher ed a couple of years ago that makes for a pretty interesting read.)

I wish I were smart enough, creative enough, focused enough to see the edgy meme that we need to start around education to invent these new things, whatever they are. I keep thinking about how back in the 70s, Wisk basically branded a problem to sell it’s detergent. “Ring around the collar” for those of you too young to remember. We need to brand this assessment problem in a way that helps the masses see it as an embarrassing inadequacy of the system.

Thoughts on how to do that?

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: education, learning, teaching

The Five Percenters

July 29, 2012 By Will Richardson

Andrew Hacker of Queens College, writing in today’s New York Times, ends a must read essay titled “Is Algebra Necessary?” with this:

Yes, young people should learn to read and write and do long division, whether they want to or not. But there is no reason to force them to grasp vectorial angles and discontinuous functions. Think of math as a huge boulder we make everyone pull, without assessing what all this pain achieves. So why require it, without alternatives or exceptions? Thus far I haven’t found a compelling answer.

Either have I. And it’s not just that I have an English teacher brain. It’s because, as Hacker notes:

…a definitive analysis by the Georgetown Center on Education and the Workforce forecasts that in the decade ahead a mere 5 percent of entry-level workers will need to be proficient in algebra or above.

Five percent! I know…we don’t know in high school which five percent of our kids will actually need to be proficient in algebra. So we make 100% of our kids try to master it just in case. That’s just silly. 

I agree with Hacker; every child needs basic math skills. And I think every child, especially today, needs a good dose of statistics in order to understand the tidal wave of data we’re subjected to on a daily basis. But I look at my own kids and wonder about all they ways they could be going deep into the things they love, becoming better, more effective learners in the process, rather than struggling through four years of stuff of which they will ever use only a small portion.

And, to be honest, this is not just about math. This is about unlearning and relearning a system that built a curriculum based on the idea that if kids didn’t get this concept or that in school, they may not get it anywhere else. The world has changed. Curriculum is everywhere. Learning math can happen at any time and almost anywhere.

Hacker asks:

Why do we subject American students to this ordeal?

I wonder too.

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: education, learning, mathematics, shifts

Our New Value Proposition

July 28, 2012 By Will Richardson

George Seimens writes about higher ed here, but I wonder to what extent this is relevant for K-12 as well:

What is valuable, however, is that which can’t be duplicated without additional input costs: personal feedback and assessment, contextualized and personalized navigation through complex topics, encouragement, questioning by a faculty member to promote deeper thinking, and a context and infrastructure of learning. Basically: human input costs make education valuable. We can’t duplicate personal interaction without spending more money. We can scale content, but we can’t scale encouragement. We can improve lecturing through peer teaching, but we can’t scale the timely interventions and nudges by faculty that influence deeper learning. [Emphasis mine.]

As schooling becomes more “personalized” through technology (and it will), our articulated value will have to change away from content delivery and more to a focus on the learning process. Still up for debate for me is to what extent to which that human input is done face to face or virtually. (See the Granny Cloud, for instance.)

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: education, learning, shifts, technology

Gaming Gains Respect

July 26, 2012 By Will Richardson

From the Shameless Self-Promotion Dept, here is the cover story on gaming I wrote for the latest issue of District Administration magazine.

Seven-year-old Chanse, a first grader in Kathleen Gerard’s classroom at PS 116 in New York City, is in a “World of Goo.” On an iPad, he’s using his index finger to pull little black animated “goo balls” around the screen and to connect them in an attempt to build what will end up being a flimsy but balanced bridge made of oily glop. He’s building across chasms and cliffs, avoiding windmills and spikes, trying to connect to a pipe that will suck up any goo that he didn’t use to score him big points.

“It’s tricky, but it’s a lot of fun,” Chanse says. “There’s so many ways you can go. But I’m good at it. On my mom’s phone, I beat the whole game.”

Read on here…

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: education, Gaming, learning, technology

  • « Previous Page
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • …
  • 12
  • Next Page »

Recent Posts

  • “Never”
  • My 2023 “Tech Cleanse” Has Begun
  • Five Themes for Educators in 2023
  • Schools in a Time of Chaos
  • Has This Crisis Really Changed Schools?

Search My Blog

Archived Posts

Copyright © 2026 Will Richardson · All Rights Reserved

Follow me on Twitter @willrich45